Why wasn't the Galactic Empire aware the shuttle Tydirium was captured by rebels?
This statement on this question doesn't seem right to me with what we know from A New Hope.
There is no evidence to say the canon Imperials knew that the shuttle was stolen.
The Galactic Empire placed a tracking device on the Millennium Falcon in A New Hope so they could use it to find the rebel base.
They could place tracking devices on all their spacecraft.
If they put one on the shuttle Tyridium, they would have known it was stolen by the rebels the moment it was missing.
Did they have hyperspace tracking devices on their small craft?
There might several explanations for this.
The Imperial Navy Knew
If they did know, then Admiral Piett would surely have known there were rebels aboard the Tyridium when it appeared out of hyperspace above the forest moon of Endor.
The Empire Did Not Track All Their Spacecraft
Maybe tracking every craft is too prohibitive.
The Rebels Disabled the Tracker
Given the near destruction of their base at Yavin, perhaps rebels realized the importance of checking every spacecraft for hidden hyperspace trackers.
Is there anything from Star Wars canon sources on this?
star-wars return-of-the-jedi
|
show 2 more comments
This statement on this question doesn't seem right to me with what we know from A New Hope.
There is no evidence to say the canon Imperials knew that the shuttle was stolen.
The Galactic Empire placed a tracking device on the Millennium Falcon in A New Hope so they could use it to find the rebel base.
They could place tracking devices on all their spacecraft.
If they put one on the shuttle Tyridium, they would have known it was stolen by the rebels the moment it was missing.
Did they have hyperspace tracking devices on their small craft?
There might several explanations for this.
The Imperial Navy Knew
If they did know, then Admiral Piett would surely have known there were rebels aboard the Tyridium when it appeared out of hyperspace above the forest moon of Endor.
The Empire Did Not Track All Their Spacecraft
Maybe tracking every craft is too prohibitive.
The Rebels Disabled the Tracker
Given the near destruction of their base at Yavin, perhaps rebels realized the importance of checking every spacecraft for hidden hyperspace trackers.
Is there anything from Star Wars canon sources on this?
star-wars return-of-the-jedi
The Tydirium was stolen during Operation Yellow Moon. Its home Star Destroyer was destroyed in the process, providing a window when the Tydirium would be unaccounted for, but not necessarily missed.
– Valorum
yesterday
If that's canon, that would be a good answer, Valorum. For my part, I'd like to know why the Imperials let just any old shuttle, whether theirs or not, show up unexpectedly without being treated as a hostile threat.
– EvilSnack
22 hours ago
@EvilSnack "it's an older code, sir, but it checks out"
– HorusKol
21 hours ago
2
@Valorum isn't it a little odd that they would accept a lone shuttle from a doomed star destroyer, claiming to be delivering supplies for a secret base? Where did the supplies come from? How did the shuttle make the trip across space without its destroyer? Goes to show how gullible the empire could be.
– Remy Lebeau
20 hours ago
@RemyLebeau Lambda-class shuttles like Tydirium have a hyperdrive. Unlike TIE fighters, they don't need a Star Destroyer to make a long distance trip.
– Null♦
20 hours ago
|
show 2 more comments
This statement on this question doesn't seem right to me with what we know from A New Hope.
There is no evidence to say the canon Imperials knew that the shuttle was stolen.
The Galactic Empire placed a tracking device on the Millennium Falcon in A New Hope so they could use it to find the rebel base.
They could place tracking devices on all their spacecraft.
If they put one on the shuttle Tyridium, they would have known it was stolen by the rebels the moment it was missing.
Did they have hyperspace tracking devices on their small craft?
There might several explanations for this.
The Imperial Navy Knew
If they did know, then Admiral Piett would surely have known there were rebels aboard the Tyridium when it appeared out of hyperspace above the forest moon of Endor.
The Empire Did Not Track All Their Spacecraft
Maybe tracking every craft is too prohibitive.
The Rebels Disabled the Tracker
Given the near destruction of their base at Yavin, perhaps rebels realized the importance of checking every spacecraft for hidden hyperspace trackers.
Is there anything from Star Wars canon sources on this?
star-wars return-of-the-jedi
This statement on this question doesn't seem right to me with what we know from A New Hope.
There is no evidence to say the canon Imperials knew that the shuttle was stolen.
The Galactic Empire placed a tracking device on the Millennium Falcon in A New Hope so they could use it to find the rebel base.
They could place tracking devices on all their spacecraft.
If they put one on the shuttle Tyridium, they would have known it was stolen by the rebels the moment it was missing.
Did they have hyperspace tracking devices on their small craft?
There might several explanations for this.
The Imperial Navy Knew
If they did know, then Admiral Piett would surely have known there were rebels aboard the Tyridium when it appeared out of hyperspace above the forest moon of Endor.
The Empire Did Not Track All Their Spacecraft
Maybe tracking every craft is too prohibitive.
The Rebels Disabled the Tracker
Given the near destruction of their base at Yavin, perhaps rebels realized the importance of checking every spacecraft for hidden hyperspace trackers.
Is there anything from Star Wars canon sources on this?
star-wars return-of-the-jedi
star-wars return-of-the-jedi
asked yesterday
LincolnManLincolnMan
1,92211430
1,92211430
The Tydirium was stolen during Operation Yellow Moon. Its home Star Destroyer was destroyed in the process, providing a window when the Tydirium would be unaccounted for, but not necessarily missed.
– Valorum
yesterday
If that's canon, that would be a good answer, Valorum. For my part, I'd like to know why the Imperials let just any old shuttle, whether theirs or not, show up unexpectedly without being treated as a hostile threat.
– EvilSnack
22 hours ago
@EvilSnack "it's an older code, sir, but it checks out"
– HorusKol
21 hours ago
2
@Valorum isn't it a little odd that they would accept a lone shuttle from a doomed star destroyer, claiming to be delivering supplies for a secret base? Where did the supplies come from? How did the shuttle make the trip across space without its destroyer? Goes to show how gullible the empire could be.
– Remy Lebeau
20 hours ago
@RemyLebeau Lambda-class shuttles like Tydirium have a hyperdrive. Unlike TIE fighters, they don't need a Star Destroyer to make a long distance trip.
– Null♦
20 hours ago
|
show 2 more comments
The Tydirium was stolen during Operation Yellow Moon. Its home Star Destroyer was destroyed in the process, providing a window when the Tydirium would be unaccounted for, but not necessarily missed.
– Valorum
yesterday
If that's canon, that would be a good answer, Valorum. For my part, I'd like to know why the Imperials let just any old shuttle, whether theirs or not, show up unexpectedly without being treated as a hostile threat.
– EvilSnack
22 hours ago
@EvilSnack "it's an older code, sir, but it checks out"
– HorusKol
21 hours ago
2
@Valorum isn't it a little odd that they would accept a lone shuttle from a doomed star destroyer, claiming to be delivering supplies for a secret base? Where did the supplies come from? How did the shuttle make the trip across space without its destroyer? Goes to show how gullible the empire could be.
– Remy Lebeau
20 hours ago
@RemyLebeau Lambda-class shuttles like Tydirium have a hyperdrive. Unlike TIE fighters, they don't need a Star Destroyer to make a long distance trip.
– Null♦
20 hours ago
The Tydirium was stolen during Operation Yellow Moon. Its home Star Destroyer was destroyed in the process, providing a window when the Tydirium would be unaccounted for, but not necessarily missed.
– Valorum
yesterday
The Tydirium was stolen during Operation Yellow Moon. Its home Star Destroyer was destroyed in the process, providing a window when the Tydirium would be unaccounted for, but not necessarily missed.
– Valorum
yesterday
If that's canon, that would be a good answer, Valorum. For my part, I'd like to know why the Imperials let just any old shuttle, whether theirs or not, show up unexpectedly without being treated as a hostile threat.
– EvilSnack
22 hours ago
If that's canon, that would be a good answer, Valorum. For my part, I'd like to know why the Imperials let just any old shuttle, whether theirs or not, show up unexpectedly without being treated as a hostile threat.
– EvilSnack
22 hours ago
@EvilSnack "it's an older code, sir, but it checks out"
– HorusKol
21 hours ago
@EvilSnack "it's an older code, sir, but it checks out"
– HorusKol
21 hours ago
2
2
@Valorum isn't it a little odd that they would accept a lone shuttle from a doomed star destroyer, claiming to be delivering supplies for a secret base? Where did the supplies come from? How did the shuttle make the trip across space without its destroyer? Goes to show how gullible the empire could be.
– Remy Lebeau
20 hours ago
@Valorum isn't it a little odd that they would accept a lone shuttle from a doomed star destroyer, claiming to be delivering supplies for a secret base? Where did the supplies come from? How did the shuttle make the trip across space without its destroyer? Goes to show how gullible the empire could be.
– Remy Lebeau
20 hours ago
@RemyLebeau Lambda-class shuttles like Tydirium have a hyperdrive. Unlike TIE fighters, they don't need a Star Destroyer to make a long distance trip.
– Null♦
20 hours ago
@RemyLebeau Lambda-class shuttles like Tydirium have a hyperdrive. Unlike TIE fighters, they don't need a Star Destroyer to make a long distance trip.
– Null♦
20 hours ago
|
show 2 more comments
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
There's no specific canon source, but hyperspace tracking wasn't seen as a thing after the Millennium Falcon was tracked until the First Order demonstrated they could do it without planting a homing device, so it was clearly unusual.
And, from a military standpoint, if you can actively track your assets, you run the risk of the enemy being able to do so as well. So it doesn't make sense for all their ships to have active homing signals; it would be a flashing "Attack me!" sign to everyone.
As to sneaking into the Endor system, there's two things: first, and easiest, the Emperor was setting up an ambush and so probably, behind the scenes, had made sure that security was porous. He knew the Rebels would likely try some sort of infiltration (since they used that tactic before, such as in Rogue One), so he had to leave a door unlocked but not make it obvious so that they wouldn't suspect that IT'S A TRAP! This would mean not sharing the information with personnel so they wouldn't act any differently (or let sympathizers or spies alert the Rebels). So, security becomes a bit lax overall. You don't follow up missing spacecraft. You don't make a point of ensuring all codes are up to date and strictly enforcing them.
Second issue: the infiltration happened after Vader had informed Jerjerrod the Emperor was showing up and work on the Death Star was behind schedule and people were getting annoyed. At that point, in love with his own life, Jerjerrod would have begged, borrowed, and stole whatever resources he could get his hands on to accelerate construction, which meant having unscheduled ships show up because he or his subordinates had called in favours or improvised a shipment outside normal channels could have been a routine thing; not having up to date codes wouldn't be unusual for a ship that wouldn't normally have been expecting to go to Endor but made an unscheduled run as part of the surge in demand for supplies and personnel.
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f205652%2fwhy-wasnt-the-galactic-empire-aware-the-shuttle-tydirium-was-captured-by-rebels%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
There's no specific canon source, but hyperspace tracking wasn't seen as a thing after the Millennium Falcon was tracked until the First Order demonstrated they could do it without planting a homing device, so it was clearly unusual.
And, from a military standpoint, if you can actively track your assets, you run the risk of the enemy being able to do so as well. So it doesn't make sense for all their ships to have active homing signals; it would be a flashing "Attack me!" sign to everyone.
As to sneaking into the Endor system, there's two things: first, and easiest, the Emperor was setting up an ambush and so probably, behind the scenes, had made sure that security was porous. He knew the Rebels would likely try some sort of infiltration (since they used that tactic before, such as in Rogue One), so he had to leave a door unlocked but not make it obvious so that they wouldn't suspect that IT'S A TRAP! This would mean not sharing the information with personnel so they wouldn't act any differently (or let sympathizers or spies alert the Rebels). So, security becomes a bit lax overall. You don't follow up missing spacecraft. You don't make a point of ensuring all codes are up to date and strictly enforcing them.
Second issue: the infiltration happened after Vader had informed Jerjerrod the Emperor was showing up and work on the Death Star was behind schedule and people were getting annoyed. At that point, in love with his own life, Jerjerrod would have begged, borrowed, and stole whatever resources he could get his hands on to accelerate construction, which meant having unscheduled ships show up because he or his subordinates had called in favours or improvised a shipment outside normal channels could have been a routine thing; not having up to date codes wouldn't be unusual for a ship that wouldn't normally have been expecting to go to Endor but made an unscheduled run as part of the surge in demand for supplies and personnel.
add a comment |
There's no specific canon source, but hyperspace tracking wasn't seen as a thing after the Millennium Falcon was tracked until the First Order demonstrated they could do it without planting a homing device, so it was clearly unusual.
And, from a military standpoint, if you can actively track your assets, you run the risk of the enemy being able to do so as well. So it doesn't make sense for all their ships to have active homing signals; it would be a flashing "Attack me!" sign to everyone.
As to sneaking into the Endor system, there's two things: first, and easiest, the Emperor was setting up an ambush and so probably, behind the scenes, had made sure that security was porous. He knew the Rebels would likely try some sort of infiltration (since they used that tactic before, such as in Rogue One), so he had to leave a door unlocked but not make it obvious so that they wouldn't suspect that IT'S A TRAP! This would mean not sharing the information with personnel so they wouldn't act any differently (or let sympathizers or spies alert the Rebels). So, security becomes a bit lax overall. You don't follow up missing spacecraft. You don't make a point of ensuring all codes are up to date and strictly enforcing them.
Second issue: the infiltration happened after Vader had informed Jerjerrod the Emperor was showing up and work on the Death Star was behind schedule and people were getting annoyed. At that point, in love with his own life, Jerjerrod would have begged, borrowed, and stole whatever resources he could get his hands on to accelerate construction, which meant having unscheduled ships show up because he or his subordinates had called in favours or improvised a shipment outside normal channels could have been a routine thing; not having up to date codes wouldn't be unusual for a ship that wouldn't normally have been expecting to go to Endor but made an unscheduled run as part of the surge in demand for supplies and personnel.
add a comment |
There's no specific canon source, but hyperspace tracking wasn't seen as a thing after the Millennium Falcon was tracked until the First Order demonstrated they could do it without planting a homing device, so it was clearly unusual.
And, from a military standpoint, if you can actively track your assets, you run the risk of the enemy being able to do so as well. So it doesn't make sense for all their ships to have active homing signals; it would be a flashing "Attack me!" sign to everyone.
As to sneaking into the Endor system, there's two things: first, and easiest, the Emperor was setting up an ambush and so probably, behind the scenes, had made sure that security was porous. He knew the Rebels would likely try some sort of infiltration (since they used that tactic before, such as in Rogue One), so he had to leave a door unlocked but not make it obvious so that they wouldn't suspect that IT'S A TRAP! This would mean not sharing the information with personnel so they wouldn't act any differently (or let sympathizers or spies alert the Rebels). So, security becomes a bit lax overall. You don't follow up missing spacecraft. You don't make a point of ensuring all codes are up to date and strictly enforcing them.
Second issue: the infiltration happened after Vader had informed Jerjerrod the Emperor was showing up and work on the Death Star was behind schedule and people were getting annoyed. At that point, in love with his own life, Jerjerrod would have begged, borrowed, and stole whatever resources he could get his hands on to accelerate construction, which meant having unscheduled ships show up because he or his subordinates had called in favours or improvised a shipment outside normal channels could have been a routine thing; not having up to date codes wouldn't be unusual for a ship that wouldn't normally have been expecting to go to Endor but made an unscheduled run as part of the surge in demand for supplies and personnel.
There's no specific canon source, but hyperspace tracking wasn't seen as a thing after the Millennium Falcon was tracked until the First Order demonstrated they could do it without planting a homing device, so it was clearly unusual.
And, from a military standpoint, if you can actively track your assets, you run the risk of the enemy being able to do so as well. So it doesn't make sense for all their ships to have active homing signals; it would be a flashing "Attack me!" sign to everyone.
As to sneaking into the Endor system, there's two things: first, and easiest, the Emperor was setting up an ambush and so probably, behind the scenes, had made sure that security was porous. He knew the Rebels would likely try some sort of infiltration (since they used that tactic before, such as in Rogue One), so he had to leave a door unlocked but not make it obvious so that they wouldn't suspect that IT'S A TRAP! This would mean not sharing the information with personnel so they wouldn't act any differently (or let sympathizers or spies alert the Rebels). So, security becomes a bit lax overall. You don't follow up missing spacecraft. You don't make a point of ensuring all codes are up to date and strictly enforcing them.
Second issue: the infiltration happened after Vader had informed Jerjerrod the Emperor was showing up and work on the Death Star was behind schedule and people were getting annoyed. At that point, in love with his own life, Jerjerrod would have begged, borrowed, and stole whatever resources he could get his hands on to accelerate construction, which meant having unscheduled ships show up because he or his subordinates had called in favours or improvised a shipment outside normal channels could have been a routine thing; not having up to date codes wouldn't be unusual for a ship that wouldn't normally have been expecting to go to Endor but made an unscheduled run as part of the surge in demand for supplies and personnel.
answered 19 hours ago
Keith MorrisonKeith Morrison
7,73711427
7,73711427
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f205652%2fwhy-wasnt-the-galactic-empire-aware-the-shuttle-tydirium-was-captured-by-rebels%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
The Tydirium was stolen during Operation Yellow Moon. Its home Star Destroyer was destroyed in the process, providing a window when the Tydirium would be unaccounted for, but not necessarily missed.
– Valorum
yesterday
If that's canon, that would be a good answer, Valorum. For my part, I'd like to know why the Imperials let just any old shuttle, whether theirs or not, show up unexpectedly without being treated as a hostile threat.
– EvilSnack
22 hours ago
@EvilSnack "it's an older code, sir, but it checks out"
– HorusKol
21 hours ago
2
@Valorum isn't it a little odd that they would accept a lone shuttle from a doomed star destroyer, claiming to be delivering supplies for a secret base? Where did the supplies come from? How did the shuttle make the trip across space without its destroyer? Goes to show how gullible the empire could be.
– Remy Lebeau
20 hours ago
@RemyLebeau Lambda-class shuttles like Tydirium have a hyperdrive. Unlike TIE fighters, they don't need a Star Destroyer to make a long distance trip.
– Null♦
20 hours ago