Does Otiluke's Resilient Sphere beat Magic Circle?





.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty{ margin-bottom:0;
}







15












$begingroup$


Magic Circle has the following effect on creatures of a specified type:




The creature can't willingly enter the cylinder by nonmagical means. If the creature tries to use teleportation or interplanar travel to do so, it must first succeed on a Charisma saving throw.




Otiluke's Resilient Sphere states:




Nothing - not physical objects, energy, or other spell effects - can pass through the barrier, in or out, though a creature in the sphere can breathe there.




Does the quoted effect from the Sphere beat the quoted effect from the Circle? In other words, could a creature of a type affected by a cast Magic Circle enclose itself in an Otiluke's Resilient Sphere and freely roll themselves into the cylinder of the Magic Circle?










share|improve this question











$endgroup$








  • 11




    $begingroup$
    they see me rollin', they hatin' ...
    $endgroup$
    – PixelMaster
    17 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    @PixelMaster and, of course, the Weird Al version "Got skills, I'm a champion at D and D". The circle is complete.
    $endgroup$
    – Reginald Blue
    13 hours ago


















15












$begingroup$


Magic Circle has the following effect on creatures of a specified type:




The creature can't willingly enter the cylinder by nonmagical means. If the creature tries to use teleportation or interplanar travel to do so, it must first succeed on a Charisma saving throw.




Otiluke's Resilient Sphere states:




Nothing - not physical objects, energy, or other spell effects - can pass through the barrier, in or out, though a creature in the sphere can breathe there.




Does the quoted effect from the Sphere beat the quoted effect from the Circle? In other words, could a creature of a type affected by a cast Magic Circle enclose itself in an Otiluke's Resilient Sphere and freely roll themselves into the cylinder of the Magic Circle?










share|improve this question











$endgroup$








  • 11




    $begingroup$
    they see me rollin', they hatin' ...
    $endgroup$
    – PixelMaster
    17 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    @PixelMaster and, of course, the Weird Al version "Got skills, I'm a champion at D and D". The circle is complete.
    $endgroup$
    – Reginald Blue
    13 hours ago














15












15








15


1



$begingroup$


Magic Circle has the following effect on creatures of a specified type:




The creature can't willingly enter the cylinder by nonmagical means. If the creature tries to use teleportation or interplanar travel to do so, it must first succeed on a Charisma saving throw.




Otiluke's Resilient Sphere states:




Nothing - not physical objects, energy, or other spell effects - can pass through the barrier, in or out, though a creature in the sphere can breathe there.




Does the quoted effect from the Sphere beat the quoted effect from the Circle? In other words, could a creature of a type affected by a cast Magic Circle enclose itself in an Otiluke's Resilient Sphere and freely roll themselves into the cylinder of the Magic Circle?










share|improve this question











$endgroup$




Magic Circle has the following effect on creatures of a specified type:




The creature can't willingly enter the cylinder by nonmagical means. If the creature tries to use teleportation or interplanar travel to do so, it must first succeed on a Charisma saving throw.




Otiluke's Resilient Sphere states:




Nothing - not physical objects, energy, or other spell effects - can pass through the barrier, in or out, though a creature in the sphere can breathe there.




Does the quoted effect from the Sphere beat the quoted effect from the Circle? In other words, could a creature of a type affected by a cast Magic Circle enclose itself in an Otiluke's Resilient Sphere and freely roll themselves into the cylinder of the Magic Circle?







dnd-5e spells






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 6 hours ago









V2Blast

26.1k590159




26.1k590159










asked 18 hours ago









VigilVigil

6,2152982




6,2152982








  • 11




    $begingroup$
    they see me rollin', they hatin' ...
    $endgroup$
    – PixelMaster
    17 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    @PixelMaster and, of course, the Weird Al version "Got skills, I'm a champion at D and D". The circle is complete.
    $endgroup$
    – Reginald Blue
    13 hours ago














  • 11




    $begingroup$
    they see me rollin', they hatin' ...
    $endgroup$
    – PixelMaster
    17 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    @PixelMaster and, of course, the Weird Al version "Got skills, I'm a champion at D and D". The circle is complete.
    $endgroup$
    – Reginald Blue
    13 hours ago








11




11




$begingroup$
they see me rollin', they hatin' ...
$endgroup$
– PixelMaster
17 hours ago




$begingroup$
they see me rollin', they hatin' ...
$endgroup$
– PixelMaster
17 hours ago




1




1




$begingroup$
@PixelMaster and, of course, the Weird Al version "Got skills, I'm a champion at D and D". The circle is complete.
$endgroup$
– Reginald Blue
13 hours ago




$begingroup$
@PixelMaster and, of course, the Weird Al version "Got skills, I'm a champion at D and D". The circle is complete.
$endgroup$
– Reginald Blue
13 hours ago










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes


















10












$begingroup$

Based on an entirely legalistic reading of the spell descriptions, it seems as if they do not interact in any meaningful way.



Specifically:




The creature can't willingly enter the cylinder by nonmagical means.




Rolling oneself across the barrier of said circle within a magically conjured resilient sphere is, arguably, a magical means of entry and so unaffected by the prohibition. It's also not a form of teleportation or interplanar travel, so it wouldn't even require a Charisma check.



Extension of this particular semantic argument to a broader scope would suggest that one can also freely enter the cylinder provided one levitates in, spider-climbs in, or walks across while wearing magic shoes. Obviously, this is deeply silly.



Unfortunately, to the best of my knowledge no more authoritative answer is available. It is very difficult to effectively prove a negative, but I have not been able to find any (e.g, designer's) statement on the interaction of these two spells. That may change; until it does, all you can do is choose to rule it (presumably differently from said ridiculous legalistic interpretation) according to your taste.






share|improve this answer











$endgroup$









  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Aren't cylinders closed at the top and bottom? Levitating in shouldn't work
    $endgroup$
    – Pierre Cathé
    16 hours ago






  • 4




    $begingroup$
    @PierreCathé Because it's a magical means, not because they'd go over the circle.
    $endgroup$
    – Miniman
    16 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Ah my bad, that seems legally correct, although it feels wrong
    $endgroup$
    – Pierre Cathé
    15 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    Thanks for the answer. Is there anything to suggest whether or not, if hypothetically this legalistic interpretation did not mean you could use any non-teleportation magic to enter the cylinder, that the Sphere blocking spell effects would be a separate reason it (and not, e.g. Levitate) could get you into the Circle?
    $endgroup$
    – Vigil
    14 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    How is walking wearing magic shoes not a nonmagical mean? The shoes don't enable the walking (unlike how levitating, rolling on a sphere, and spider-climbing necessitate the magic for the action).
    $endgroup$
    – David Coffron
    14 hours ago





















4












$begingroup$

Yes, you can enter the circle



The resilient sphere effectively excludes anything it encloses from outside spell effect areas. As the effect of the magic circle originates outside, it does not have any effect on a creature rolling inside the sphere, as it is not considered to be in its area of effect.






share|improve this answer









$endgroup$














    Your Answer





    StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
    return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
    StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
    StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["\$", "\$"]]);
    });
    });
    }, "mathjax-editing");

    StackExchange.ready(function() {
    var channelOptions = {
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "122"
    };
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
    createEditor();
    });
    }
    else {
    createEditor();
    }
    });

    function createEditor() {
    StackExchange.prepareEditor({
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
    convertImagesToLinks: false,
    noModals: true,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: null,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    imageUploader: {
    brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
    contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
    allowUrls: true
    },
    noCode: true, onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    });


    }
    });














    draft saved

    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function () {
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f144612%2fdoes-otilukes-resilient-sphere-beat-magic-circle%23new-answer', 'question_page');
    }
    );

    Post as a guest















    Required, but never shown

























    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes








    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes









    10












    $begingroup$

    Based on an entirely legalistic reading of the spell descriptions, it seems as if they do not interact in any meaningful way.



    Specifically:




    The creature can't willingly enter the cylinder by nonmagical means.




    Rolling oneself across the barrier of said circle within a magically conjured resilient sphere is, arguably, a magical means of entry and so unaffected by the prohibition. It's also not a form of teleportation or interplanar travel, so it wouldn't even require a Charisma check.



    Extension of this particular semantic argument to a broader scope would suggest that one can also freely enter the cylinder provided one levitates in, spider-climbs in, or walks across while wearing magic shoes. Obviously, this is deeply silly.



    Unfortunately, to the best of my knowledge no more authoritative answer is available. It is very difficult to effectively prove a negative, but I have not been able to find any (e.g, designer's) statement on the interaction of these two spells. That may change; until it does, all you can do is choose to rule it (presumably differently from said ridiculous legalistic interpretation) according to your taste.






    share|improve this answer











    $endgroup$









    • 1




      $begingroup$
      Aren't cylinders closed at the top and bottom? Levitating in shouldn't work
      $endgroup$
      – Pierre Cathé
      16 hours ago






    • 4




      $begingroup$
      @PierreCathé Because it's a magical means, not because they'd go over the circle.
      $endgroup$
      – Miniman
      16 hours ago






    • 1




      $begingroup$
      Ah my bad, that seems legally correct, although it feels wrong
      $endgroup$
      – Pierre Cathé
      15 hours ago










    • $begingroup$
      Thanks for the answer. Is there anything to suggest whether or not, if hypothetically this legalistic interpretation did not mean you could use any non-teleportation magic to enter the cylinder, that the Sphere blocking spell effects would be a separate reason it (and not, e.g. Levitate) could get you into the Circle?
      $endgroup$
      – Vigil
      14 hours ago










    • $begingroup$
      How is walking wearing magic shoes not a nonmagical mean? The shoes don't enable the walking (unlike how levitating, rolling on a sphere, and spider-climbing necessitate the magic for the action).
      $endgroup$
      – David Coffron
      14 hours ago


















    10












    $begingroup$

    Based on an entirely legalistic reading of the spell descriptions, it seems as if they do not interact in any meaningful way.



    Specifically:




    The creature can't willingly enter the cylinder by nonmagical means.




    Rolling oneself across the barrier of said circle within a magically conjured resilient sphere is, arguably, a magical means of entry and so unaffected by the prohibition. It's also not a form of teleportation or interplanar travel, so it wouldn't even require a Charisma check.



    Extension of this particular semantic argument to a broader scope would suggest that one can also freely enter the cylinder provided one levitates in, spider-climbs in, or walks across while wearing magic shoes. Obviously, this is deeply silly.



    Unfortunately, to the best of my knowledge no more authoritative answer is available. It is very difficult to effectively prove a negative, but I have not been able to find any (e.g, designer's) statement on the interaction of these two spells. That may change; until it does, all you can do is choose to rule it (presumably differently from said ridiculous legalistic interpretation) according to your taste.






    share|improve this answer











    $endgroup$









    • 1




      $begingroup$
      Aren't cylinders closed at the top and bottom? Levitating in shouldn't work
      $endgroup$
      – Pierre Cathé
      16 hours ago






    • 4




      $begingroup$
      @PierreCathé Because it's a magical means, not because they'd go over the circle.
      $endgroup$
      – Miniman
      16 hours ago






    • 1




      $begingroup$
      Ah my bad, that seems legally correct, although it feels wrong
      $endgroup$
      – Pierre Cathé
      15 hours ago










    • $begingroup$
      Thanks for the answer. Is there anything to suggest whether or not, if hypothetically this legalistic interpretation did not mean you could use any non-teleportation magic to enter the cylinder, that the Sphere blocking spell effects would be a separate reason it (and not, e.g. Levitate) could get you into the Circle?
      $endgroup$
      – Vigil
      14 hours ago










    • $begingroup$
      How is walking wearing magic shoes not a nonmagical mean? The shoes don't enable the walking (unlike how levitating, rolling on a sphere, and spider-climbing necessitate the magic for the action).
      $endgroup$
      – David Coffron
      14 hours ago
















    10












    10








    10





    $begingroup$

    Based on an entirely legalistic reading of the spell descriptions, it seems as if they do not interact in any meaningful way.



    Specifically:




    The creature can't willingly enter the cylinder by nonmagical means.




    Rolling oneself across the barrier of said circle within a magically conjured resilient sphere is, arguably, a magical means of entry and so unaffected by the prohibition. It's also not a form of teleportation or interplanar travel, so it wouldn't even require a Charisma check.



    Extension of this particular semantic argument to a broader scope would suggest that one can also freely enter the cylinder provided one levitates in, spider-climbs in, or walks across while wearing magic shoes. Obviously, this is deeply silly.



    Unfortunately, to the best of my knowledge no more authoritative answer is available. It is very difficult to effectively prove a negative, but I have not been able to find any (e.g, designer's) statement on the interaction of these two spells. That may change; until it does, all you can do is choose to rule it (presumably differently from said ridiculous legalistic interpretation) according to your taste.






    share|improve this answer











    $endgroup$



    Based on an entirely legalistic reading of the spell descriptions, it seems as if they do not interact in any meaningful way.



    Specifically:




    The creature can't willingly enter the cylinder by nonmagical means.




    Rolling oneself across the barrier of said circle within a magically conjured resilient sphere is, arguably, a magical means of entry and so unaffected by the prohibition. It's also not a form of teleportation or interplanar travel, so it wouldn't even require a Charisma check.



    Extension of this particular semantic argument to a broader scope would suggest that one can also freely enter the cylinder provided one levitates in, spider-climbs in, or walks across while wearing magic shoes. Obviously, this is deeply silly.



    Unfortunately, to the best of my knowledge no more authoritative answer is available. It is very difficult to effectively prove a negative, but I have not been able to find any (e.g, designer's) statement on the interaction of these two spells. That may change; until it does, all you can do is choose to rule it (presumably differently from said ridiculous legalistic interpretation) according to your taste.







    share|improve this answer














    share|improve this answer



    share|improve this answer








    edited 6 hours ago









    V2Blast

    26.1k590159




    26.1k590159










    answered 16 hours ago









    a computing puna computing pun

    3,6691633




    3,6691633








    • 1




      $begingroup$
      Aren't cylinders closed at the top and bottom? Levitating in shouldn't work
      $endgroup$
      – Pierre Cathé
      16 hours ago






    • 4




      $begingroup$
      @PierreCathé Because it's a magical means, not because they'd go over the circle.
      $endgroup$
      – Miniman
      16 hours ago






    • 1




      $begingroup$
      Ah my bad, that seems legally correct, although it feels wrong
      $endgroup$
      – Pierre Cathé
      15 hours ago










    • $begingroup$
      Thanks for the answer. Is there anything to suggest whether or not, if hypothetically this legalistic interpretation did not mean you could use any non-teleportation magic to enter the cylinder, that the Sphere blocking spell effects would be a separate reason it (and not, e.g. Levitate) could get you into the Circle?
      $endgroup$
      – Vigil
      14 hours ago










    • $begingroup$
      How is walking wearing magic shoes not a nonmagical mean? The shoes don't enable the walking (unlike how levitating, rolling on a sphere, and spider-climbing necessitate the magic for the action).
      $endgroup$
      – David Coffron
      14 hours ago
















    • 1




      $begingroup$
      Aren't cylinders closed at the top and bottom? Levitating in shouldn't work
      $endgroup$
      – Pierre Cathé
      16 hours ago






    • 4




      $begingroup$
      @PierreCathé Because it's a magical means, not because they'd go over the circle.
      $endgroup$
      – Miniman
      16 hours ago






    • 1




      $begingroup$
      Ah my bad, that seems legally correct, although it feels wrong
      $endgroup$
      – Pierre Cathé
      15 hours ago










    • $begingroup$
      Thanks for the answer. Is there anything to suggest whether or not, if hypothetically this legalistic interpretation did not mean you could use any non-teleportation magic to enter the cylinder, that the Sphere blocking spell effects would be a separate reason it (and not, e.g. Levitate) could get you into the Circle?
      $endgroup$
      – Vigil
      14 hours ago










    • $begingroup$
      How is walking wearing magic shoes not a nonmagical mean? The shoes don't enable the walking (unlike how levitating, rolling on a sphere, and spider-climbing necessitate the magic for the action).
      $endgroup$
      – David Coffron
      14 hours ago










    1




    1




    $begingroup$
    Aren't cylinders closed at the top and bottom? Levitating in shouldn't work
    $endgroup$
    – Pierre Cathé
    16 hours ago




    $begingroup$
    Aren't cylinders closed at the top and bottom? Levitating in shouldn't work
    $endgroup$
    – Pierre Cathé
    16 hours ago




    4




    4




    $begingroup$
    @PierreCathé Because it's a magical means, not because they'd go over the circle.
    $endgroup$
    – Miniman
    16 hours ago




    $begingroup$
    @PierreCathé Because it's a magical means, not because they'd go over the circle.
    $endgroup$
    – Miniman
    16 hours ago




    1




    1




    $begingroup$
    Ah my bad, that seems legally correct, although it feels wrong
    $endgroup$
    – Pierre Cathé
    15 hours ago




    $begingroup$
    Ah my bad, that seems legally correct, although it feels wrong
    $endgroup$
    – Pierre Cathé
    15 hours ago












    $begingroup$
    Thanks for the answer. Is there anything to suggest whether or not, if hypothetically this legalistic interpretation did not mean you could use any non-teleportation magic to enter the cylinder, that the Sphere blocking spell effects would be a separate reason it (and not, e.g. Levitate) could get you into the Circle?
    $endgroup$
    – Vigil
    14 hours ago




    $begingroup$
    Thanks for the answer. Is there anything to suggest whether or not, if hypothetically this legalistic interpretation did not mean you could use any non-teleportation magic to enter the cylinder, that the Sphere blocking spell effects would be a separate reason it (and not, e.g. Levitate) could get you into the Circle?
    $endgroup$
    – Vigil
    14 hours ago












    $begingroup$
    How is walking wearing magic shoes not a nonmagical mean? The shoes don't enable the walking (unlike how levitating, rolling on a sphere, and spider-climbing necessitate the magic for the action).
    $endgroup$
    – David Coffron
    14 hours ago






    $begingroup$
    How is walking wearing magic shoes not a nonmagical mean? The shoes don't enable the walking (unlike how levitating, rolling on a sphere, and spider-climbing necessitate the magic for the action).
    $endgroup$
    – David Coffron
    14 hours ago















    4












    $begingroup$

    Yes, you can enter the circle



    The resilient sphere effectively excludes anything it encloses from outside spell effect areas. As the effect of the magic circle originates outside, it does not have any effect on a creature rolling inside the sphere, as it is not considered to be in its area of effect.






    share|improve this answer









    $endgroup$


















      4












      $begingroup$

      Yes, you can enter the circle



      The resilient sphere effectively excludes anything it encloses from outside spell effect areas. As the effect of the magic circle originates outside, it does not have any effect on a creature rolling inside the sphere, as it is not considered to be in its area of effect.






      share|improve this answer









      $endgroup$
















        4












        4








        4





        $begingroup$

        Yes, you can enter the circle



        The resilient sphere effectively excludes anything it encloses from outside spell effect areas. As the effect of the magic circle originates outside, it does not have any effect on a creature rolling inside the sphere, as it is not considered to be in its area of effect.






        share|improve this answer









        $endgroup$



        Yes, you can enter the circle



        The resilient sphere effectively excludes anything it encloses from outside spell effect areas. As the effect of the magic circle originates outside, it does not have any effect on a creature rolling inside the sphere, as it is not considered to be in its area of effect.







        share|improve this answer












        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer










        answered 14 hours ago









        SzegaSzega

        39.9k4163199




        39.9k4163199






























            draft saved

            draft discarded




















































            Thanks for contributing an answer to Role-playing Games Stack Exchange!


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f144612%2fdoes-otilukes-resilient-sphere-beat-magic-circle%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown





















































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown

































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown







            Popular posts from this blog

            How to label and detect the document text images

            Vallis Paradisi

            Tabula Rosettana