Why do we charge our flashes?












9















So whenever we want to shoot our flash before taking a photo. we have to charge it first.



What is the point of the charging our flashes? Aren't their power directly supplied by the battery of our camera?



Please answer for the built in flash on the 2000D and the traditional hot shoe Xenon flashes.



Perhaps these hot shoe xenon flashes have their own batteries charged by the slow hot shoe port. Who knows?










share|improve this question




















  • 1





    Just a comment regarding [...] for the built in LED on the 2000D: AFAIK, the EOS 2000D's flash is not a LED. In fact, I only know of video LEDs and modelling LEDs (so continuous light that might be placed onto a flash unit), but no flash unit comprised of LEDs.

    – flolilolilo
    14 hours ago








  • 1





    Also, even a pulsed LED light strong enough to be useful for more than a few meters would likely involve a pre-charged capacitor - once you need a few amperes, you'll run into issues like creating brownouts, ground bounce, battery stress if you power that straight off the camera battery....

    – rackandboneman
    11 hours ago






  • 1





    Also, a standard hot shoe, and most brand-specific hot shoe layouts, haven't any charging power available. Sony MIS/iISO offers access to the camera battery, but AFAIK it's not used to power any full size flashes...

    – rackandboneman
    5 hours ago


















9















So whenever we want to shoot our flash before taking a photo. we have to charge it first.



What is the point of the charging our flashes? Aren't their power directly supplied by the battery of our camera?



Please answer for the built in flash on the 2000D and the traditional hot shoe Xenon flashes.



Perhaps these hot shoe xenon flashes have their own batteries charged by the slow hot shoe port. Who knows?










share|improve this question




















  • 1





    Just a comment regarding [...] for the built in LED on the 2000D: AFAIK, the EOS 2000D's flash is not a LED. In fact, I only know of video LEDs and modelling LEDs (so continuous light that might be placed onto a flash unit), but no flash unit comprised of LEDs.

    – flolilolilo
    14 hours ago








  • 1





    Also, even a pulsed LED light strong enough to be useful for more than a few meters would likely involve a pre-charged capacitor - once you need a few amperes, you'll run into issues like creating brownouts, ground bounce, battery stress if you power that straight off the camera battery....

    – rackandboneman
    11 hours ago






  • 1





    Also, a standard hot shoe, and most brand-specific hot shoe layouts, haven't any charging power available. Sony MIS/iISO offers access to the camera battery, but AFAIK it's not used to power any full size flashes...

    – rackandboneman
    5 hours ago
















9












9








9








So whenever we want to shoot our flash before taking a photo. we have to charge it first.



What is the point of the charging our flashes? Aren't their power directly supplied by the battery of our camera?



Please answer for the built in flash on the 2000D and the traditional hot shoe Xenon flashes.



Perhaps these hot shoe xenon flashes have their own batteries charged by the slow hot shoe port. Who knows?










share|improve this question
















So whenever we want to shoot our flash before taking a photo. we have to charge it first.



What is the point of the charging our flashes? Aren't their power directly supplied by the battery of our camera?



Please answer for the built in flash on the 2000D and the traditional hot shoe Xenon flashes.



Perhaps these hot shoe xenon flashes have their own batteries charged by the slow hot shoe port. Who knows?







flash off-camera-flash hotshoe-flash popup-flash






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 9 hours ago







Jonathan Irons

















asked 18 hours ago









Jonathan IronsJonathan Irons

33610




33610








  • 1





    Just a comment regarding [...] for the built in LED on the 2000D: AFAIK, the EOS 2000D's flash is not a LED. In fact, I only know of video LEDs and modelling LEDs (so continuous light that might be placed onto a flash unit), but no flash unit comprised of LEDs.

    – flolilolilo
    14 hours ago








  • 1





    Also, even a pulsed LED light strong enough to be useful for more than a few meters would likely involve a pre-charged capacitor - once you need a few amperes, you'll run into issues like creating brownouts, ground bounce, battery stress if you power that straight off the camera battery....

    – rackandboneman
    11 hours ago






  • 1





    Also, a standard hot shoe, and most brand-specific hot shoe layouts, haven't any charging power available. Sony MIS/iISO offers access to the camera battery, but AFAIK it's not used to power any full size flashes...

    – rackandboneman
    5 hours ago
















  • 1





    Just a comment regarding [...] for the built in LED on the 2000D: AFAIK, the EOS 2000D's flash is not a LED. In fact, I only know of video LEDs and modelling LEDs (so continuous light that might be placed onto a flash unit), but no flash unit comprised of LEDs.

    – flolilolilo
    14 hours ago








  • 1





    Also, even a pulsed LED light strong enough to be useful for more than a few meters would likely involve a pre-charged capacitor - once you need a few amperes, you'll run into issues like creating brownouts, ground bounce, battery stress if you power that straight off the camera battery....

    – rackandboneman
    11 hours ago






  • 1





    Also, a standard hot shoe, and most brand-specific hot shoe layouts, haven't any charging power available. Sony MIS/iISO offers access to the camera battery, but AFAIK it's not used to power any full size flashes...

    – rackandboneman
    5 hours ago










1




1





Just a comment regarding [...] for the built in LED on the 2000D: AFAIK, the EOS 2000D's flash is not a LED. In fact, I only know of video LEDs and modelling LEDs (so continuous light that might be placed onto a flash unit), but no flash unit comprised of LEDs.

– flolilolilo
14 hours ago







Just a comment regarding [...] for the built in LED on the 2000D: AFAIK, the EOS 2000D's flash is not a LED. In fact, I only know of video LEDs and modelling LEDs (so continuous light that might be placed onto a flash unit), but no flash unit comprised of LEDs.

– flolilolilo
14 hours ago






1




1





Also, even a pulsed LED light strong enough to be useful for more than a few meters would likely involve a pre-charged capacitor - once you need a few amperes, you'll run into issues like creating brownouts, ground bounce, battery stress if you power that straight off the camera battery....

– rackandboneman
11 hours ago





Also, even a pulsed LED light strong enough to be useful for more than a few meters would likely involve a pre-charged capacitor - once you need a few amperes, you'll run into issues like creating brownouts, ground bounce, battery stress if you power that straight off the camera battery....

– rackandboneman
11 hours ago




1




1





Also, a standard hot shoe, and most brand-specific hot shoe layouts, haven't any charging power available. Sony MIS/iISO offers access to the camera battery, but AFAIK it's not used to power any full size flashes...

– rackandboneman
5 hours ago







Also, a standard hot shoe, and most brand-specific hot shoe layouts, haven't any charging power available. Sony MIS/iISO offers access to the camera battery, but AFAIK it's not used to power any full size flashes...

– rackandboneman
5 hours ago












1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















23














The peak power at work when a flash is being discharged is extreme.



Example: a classic Metz 45CT (a large but still handheld unit) on full manual power delivers around 90 watt-seconds of electrical output to the flash tube in 1/300s. That means there are 27000 watts at work for a short time.



A 27000 watt lightbulb (BTW, your flash is much brighter than that - more efficient!) would need the ampacity of around eight european household sockets (230V, fused at 13 or 16 amps) to operate, since it would draw around 120 ampere from them. At the voltage levels xenon flash tubes typically operate at, around 80 amperes will flow; if you wanted to pull that energy "live" from a 5-6V battery, you'd need to pull around 5000 amperes AND instantaneously convert them to around 80 amperes at high voltage. Batteries that could deliver 5000 amps - while not wasting most of the power as heat generated across their internal resistance - for a short duration and live certainly exist - you are looking at starter batteries for big lorries, which are rather inconvenient to lug around. Also, a 5000 ampere current pulse is quite a magnetic nuisance if there is anything either ferromagnetic or intended as an electrical conductor near the conductors used.



Your average "big" speedlite, btw, will be around half the power described here (but might in some cases reach the same or higher peak currents in order to discharge even faster), an in-camera flash will be a fraction of these numbers - but still inconvenient to build any other way.



If you need a short, massive current pulse, the best energy source available in engineering is a previously charged capacitor (metal-paper or electrolytic type, not dual-layer "supercap"). This energy storage device is large for its storage capacity if you compare it to a battery - but able to respond far quicker to high current demand, since a) there is no chemical energy conversion involved in its operation, b) the relevant current path only involves metallic, very conductive parts instead of ionic conductors (aka electrolytes. An electrolytic capacitor, btw, does use its electrolyte for chemical self-upkeep, not for chemical energy storage or electrical connectivity).



Also, since the charge in a a capacitor is limited, it allows portioning total energy to what the flashlamp can safely take. This allows a flash in manual mode to just completely discharge the capacitor until it is nearly empty (when the remaining charge can only deliver voltage below the quench voltage of the flashlamp) without complex control circuitry - and at the same time gives you a safety fallback when working with dynamically controlled power levels (telecomputer or TTL mode), leaving no way for catastrophic circuit failure in combination with several kilowatts of constant power available turning into a massive safety hazard. A handheld-sized efficient electrical near point light source with 27000W input, driven constantly, would first severely damage your eyes and then self destroy violently (think of a welding arc - dangerously bright, and it melts metal).






share|improve this answer


























  • There's your capacitor. Discharged and shorted for your safety.

    – rackandboneman
    14 hours ago











  • Perfect, thanks. :)

    – mattdm
    14 hours ago






  • 3





    Is this still "Photography" StackExchange or this is the "Physics" section :o)

    – Rafael
    11 hours ago











Your Answer








StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "61"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});

function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});


}
});














draft saved

draft discarded


















StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fphoto.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f105156%2fwhy-do-we-charge-our-flashes%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown

























1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes








1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









23














The peak power at work when a flash is being discharged is extreme.



Example: a classic Metz 45CT (a large but still handheld unit) on full manual power delivers around 90 watt-seconds of electrical output to the flash tube in 1/300s. That means there are 27000 watts at work for a short time.



A 27000 watt lightbulb (BTW, your flash is much brighter than that - more efficient!) would need the ampacity of around eight european household sockets (230V, fused at 13 or 16 amps) to operate, since it would draw around 120 ampere from them. At the voltage levels xenon flash tubes typically operate at, around 80 amperes will flow; if you wanted to pull that energy "live" from a 5-6V battery, you'd need to pull around 5000 amperes AND instantaneously convert them to around 80 amperes at high voltage. Batteries that could deliver 5000 amps - while not wasting most of the power as heat generated across their internal resistance - for a short duration and live certainly exist - you are looking at starter batteries for big lorries, which are rather inconvenient to lug around. Also, a 5000 ampere current pulse is quite a magnetic nuisance if there is anything either ferromagnetic or intended as an electrical conductor near the conductors used.



Your average "big" speedlite, btw, will be around half the power described here (but might in some cases reach the same or higher peak currents in order to discharge even faster), an in-camera flash will be a fraction of these numbers - but still inconvenient to build any other way.



If you need a short, massive current pulse, the best energy source available in engineering is a previously charged capacitor (metal-paper or electrolytic type, not dual-layer "supercap"). This energy storage device is large for its storage capacity if you compare it to a battery - but able to respond far quicker to high current demand, since a) there is no chemical energy conversion involved in its operation, b) the relevant current path only involves metallic, very conductive parts instead of ionic conductors (aka electrolytes. An electrolytic capacitor, btw, does use its electrolyte for chemical self-upkeep, not for chemical energy storage or electrical connectivity).



Also, since the charge in a a capacitor is limited, it allows portioning total energy to what the flashlamp can safely take. This allows a flash in manual mode to just completely discharge the capacitor until it is nearly empty (when the remaining charge can only deliver voltage below the quench voltage of the flashlamp) without complex control circuitry - and at the same time gives you a safety fallback when working with dynamically controlled power levels (telecomputer or TTL mode), leaving no way for catastrophic circuit failure in combination with several kilowatts of constant power available turning into a massive safety hazard. A handheld-sized efficient electrical near point light source with 27000W input, driven constantly, would first severely damage your eyes and then self destroy violently (think of a welding arc - dangerously bright, and it melts metal).






share|improve this answer


























  • There's your capacitor. Discharged and shorted for your safety.

    – rackandboneman
    14 hours ago











  • Perfect, thanks. :)

    – mattdm
    14 hours ago






  • 3





    Is this still "Photography" StackExchange or this is the "Physics" section :o)

    – Rafael
    11 hours ago
















23














The peak power at work when a flash is being discharged is extreme.



Example: a classic Metz 45CT (a large but still handheld unit) on full manual power delivers around 90 watt-seconds of electrical output to the flash tube in 1/300s. That means there are 27000 watts at work for a short time.



A 27000 watt lightbulb (BTW, your flash is much brighter than that - more efficient!) would need the ampacity of around eight european household sockets (230V, fused at 13 or 16 amps) to operate, since it would draw around 120 ampere from them. At the voltage levels xenon flash tubes typically operate at, around 80 amperes will flow; if you wanted to pull that energy "live" from a 5-6V battery, you'd need to pull around 5000 amperes AND instantaneously convert them to around 80 amperes at high voltage. Batteries that could deliver 5000 amps - while not wasting most of the power as heat generated across their internal resistance - for a short duration and live certainly exist - you are looking at starter batteries for big lorries, which are rather inconvenient to lug around. Also, a 5000 ampere current pulse is quite a magnetic nuisance if there is anything either ferromagnetic or intended as an electrical conductor near the conductors used.



Your average "big" speedlite, btw, will be around half the power described here (but might in some cases reach the same or higher peak currents in order to discharge even faster), an in-camera flash will be a fraction of these numbers - but still inconvenient to build any other way.



If you need a short, massive current pulse, the best energy source available in engineering is a previously charged capacitor (metal-paper or electrolytic type, not dual-layer "supercap"). This energy storage device is large for its storage capacity if you compare it to a battery - but able to respond far quicker to high current demand, since a) there is no chemical energy conversion involved in its operation, b) the relevant current path only involves metallic, very conductive parts instead of ionic conductors (aka electrolytes. An electrolytic capacitor, btw, does use its electrolyte for chemical self-upkeep, not for chemical energy storage or electrical connectivity).



Also, since the charge in a a capacitor is limited, it allows portioning total energy to what the flashlamp can safely take. This allows a flash in manual mode to just completely discharge the capacitor until it is nearly empty (when the remaining charge can only deliver voltage below the quench voltage of the flashlamp) without complex control circuitry - and at the same time gives you a safety fallback when working with dynamically controlled power levels (telecomputer or TTL mode), leaving no way for catastrophic circuit failure in combination with several kilowatts of constant power available turning into a massive safety hazard. A handheld-sized efficient electrical near point light source with 27000W input, driven constantly, would first severely damage your eyes and then self destroy violently (think of a welding arc - dangerously bright, and it melts metal).






share|improve this answer


























  • There's your capacitor. Discharged and shorted for your safety.

    – rackandboneman
    14 hours ago











  • Perfect, thanks. :)

    – mattdm
    14 hours ago






  • 3





    Is this still "Photography" StackExchange or this is the "Physics" section :o)

    – Rafael
    11 hours ago














23












23








23







The peak power at work when a flash is being discharged is extreme.



Example: a classic Metz 45CT (a large but still handheld unit) on full manual power delivers around 90 watt-seconds of electrical output to the flash tube in 1/300s. That means there are 27000 watts at work for a short time.



A 27000 watt lightbulb (BTW, your flash is much brighter than that - more efficient!) would need the ampacity of around eight european household sockets (230V, fused at 13 or 16 amps) to operate, since it would draw around 120 ampere from them. At the voltage levels xenon flash tubes typically operate at, around 80 amperes will flow; if you wanted to pull that energy "live" from a 5-6V battery, you'd need to pull around 5000 amperes AND instantaneously convert them to around 80 amperes at high voltage. Batteries that could deliver 5000 amps - while not wasting most of the power as heat generated across their internal resistance - for a short duration and live certainly exist - you are looking at starter batteries for big lorries, which are rather inconvenient to lug around. Also, a 5000 ampere current pulse is quite a magnetic nuisance if there is anything either ferromagnetic or intended as an electrical conductor near the conductors used.



Your average "big" speedlite, btw, will be around half the power described here (but might in some cases reach the same or higher peak currents in order to discharge even faster), an in-camera flash will be a fraction of these numbers - but still inconvenient to build any other way.



If you need a short, massive current pulse, the best energy source available in engineering is a previously charged capacitor (metal-paper or electrolytic type, not dual-layer "supercap"). This energy storage device is large for its storage capacity if you compare it to a battery - but able to respond far quicker to high current demand, since a) there is no chemical energy conversion involved in its operation, b) the relevant current path only involves metallic, very conductive parts instead of ionic conductors (aka electrolytes. An electrolytic capacitor, btw, does use its electrolyte for chemical self-upkeep, not for chemical energy storage or electrical connectivity).



Also, since the charge in a a capacitor is limited, it allows portioning total energy to what the flashlamp can safely take. This allows a flash in manual mode to just completely discharge the capacitor until it is nearly empty (when the remaining charge can only deliver voltage below the quench voltage of the flashlamp) without complex control circuitry - and at the same time gives you a safety fallback when working with dynamically controlled power levels (telecomputer or TTL mode), leaving no way for catastrophic circuit failure in combination with several kilowatts of constant power available turning into a massive safety hazard. A handheld-sized efficient electrical near point light source with 27000W input, driven constantly, would first severely damage your eyes and then self destroy violently (think of a welding arc - dangerously bright, and it melts metal).






share|improve this answer















The peak power at work when a flash is being discharged is extreme.



Example: a classic Metz 45CT (a large but still handheld unit) on full manual power delivers around 90 watt-seconds of electrical output to the flash tube in 1/300s. That means there are 27000 watts at work for a short time.



A 27000 watt lightbulb (BTW, your flash is much brighter than that - more efficient!) would need the ampacity of around eight european household sockets (230V, fused at 13 or 16 amps) to operate, since it would draw around 120 ampere from them. At the voltage levels xenon flash tubes typically operate at, around 80 amperes will flow; if you wanted to pull that energy "live" from a 5-6V battery, you'd need to pull around 5000 amperes AND instantaneously convert them to around 80 amperes at high voltage. Batteries that could deliver 5000 amps - while not wasting most of the power as heat generated across their internal resistance - for a short duration and live certainly exist - you are looking at starter batteries for big lorries, which are rather inconvenient to lug around. Also, a 5000 ampere current pulse is quite a magnetic nuisance if there is anything either ferromagnetic or intended as an electrical conductor near the conductors used.



Your average "big" speedlite, btw, will be around half the power described here (but might in some cases reach the same or higher peak currents in order to discharge even faster), an in-camera flash will be a fraction of these numbers - but still inconvenient to build any other way.



If you need a short, massive current pulse, the best energy source available in engineering is a previously charged capacitor (metal-paper or electrolytic type, not dual-layer "supercap"). This energy storage device is large for its storage capacity if you compare it to a battery - but able to respond far quicker to high current demand, since a) there is no chemical energy conversion involved in its operation, b) the relevant current path only involves metallic, very conductive parts instead of ionic conductors (aka electrolytes. An electrolytic capacitor, btw, does use its electrolyte for chemical self-upkeep, not for chemical energy storage or electrical connectivity).



Also, since the charge in a a capacitor is limited, it allows portioning total energy to what the flashlamp can safely take. This allows a flash in manual mode to just completely discharge the capacitor until it is nearly empty (when the remaining charge can only deliver voltage below the quench voltage of the flashlamp) without complex control circuitry - and at the same time gives you a safety fallback when working with dynamically controlled power levels (telecomputer or TTL mode), leaving no way for catastrophic circuit failure in combination with several kilowatts of constant power available turning into a massive safety hazard. A handheld-sized efficient electrical near point light source with 27000W input, driven constantly, would first severely damage your eyes and then self destroy violently (think of a welding arc - dangerously bright, and it melts metal).







share|improve this answer














share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer








edited 14 hours ago

























answered 17 hours ago









rackandbonemanrackandboneman

1,978516




1,978516













  • There's your capacitor. Discharged and shorted for your safety.

    – rackandboneman
    14 hours ago











  • Perfect, thanks. :)

    – mattdm
    14 hours ago






  • 3





    Is this still "Photography" StackExchange or this is the "Physics" section :o)

    – Rafael
    11 hours ago



















  • There's your capacitor. Discharged and shorted for your safety.

    – rackandboneman
    14 hours ago











  • Perfect, thanks. :)

    – mattdm
    14 hours ago






  • 3





    Is this still "Photography" StackExchange or this is the "Physics" section :o)

    – Rafael
    11 hours ago

















There's your capacitor. Discharged and shorted for your safety.

– rackandboneman
14 hours ago





There's your capacitor. Discharged and shorted for your safety.

– rackandboneman
14 hours ago













Perfect, thanks. :)

– mattdm
14 hours ago





Perfect, thanks. :)

– mattdm
14 hours ago




3




3





Is this still "Photography" StackExchange or this is the "Physics" section :o)

– Rafael
11 hours ago





Is this still "Photography" StackExchange or this is the "Physics" section :o)

– Rafael
11 hours ago


















draft saved

draft discarded




















































Thanks for contributing an answer to Photography Stack Exchange!


  • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

But avoid



  • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

  • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




draft saved


draft discarded














StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fphoto.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f105156%2fwhy-do-we-charge-our-flashes%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown





















































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown

































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown







Popular posts from this blog

How to label and detect the document text images

Vallis Paradisi

Tabula Rosettana