Is the “Bhaja Govindam” prayer attributed to Adi Sankara only a Bhakti text?












0















First of all - "Govinda" not being "Narayana" can refer to any deity even by Vaishnavite rules.



But then a blog named [shastranethralaya](
http://blog.shastranethralaya.org/?p=165)



says




Normally this is taken as a Bhakti text. But we’ll see it in its true form, like any other Acharya’s text this is also another which deals only with Vedanta.







So this stanzas summary is, they have to worship the Lord who is none other than the Self instead of wasting our time in different forms of action. Since no action can make us attain the ever attained.











share|improve this question

























  • Yes, Govinda = Krishna = Vishnu = brahman = Atman

    – Lazy Lubber
    1 hour ago











  • Govinda = Krishna = Vishnu = brahman = Atman = Ganesha =Durga=Murugan=(for some people) Sai Baba. @Lazy Lubber

    – S K
    1 hour ago








  • 5





    1=2 for some people

    – ram
    1 hour ago











  • Bhakti and jnana.

    – Lazy Lubber
    1 hour ago











  • Vedanta is itself bhakti. Vedanta teaches both bhakti and jnana. Bhakti=Jnana

    – Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
    1 hour ago
















0















First of all - "Govinda" not being "Narayana" can refer to any deity even by Vaishnavite rules.



But then a blog named [shastranethralaya](
http://blog.shastranethralaya.org/?p=165)



says




Normally this is taken as a Bhakti text. But we’ll see it in its true form, like any other Acharya’s text this is also another which deals only with Vedanta.







So this stanzas summary is, they have to worship the Lord who is none other than the Self instead of wasting our time in different forms of action. Since no action can make us attain the ever attained.











share|improve this question

























  • Yes, Govinda = Krishna = Vishnu = brahman = Atman

    – Lazy Lubber
    1 hour ago











  • Govinda = Krishna = Vishnu = brahman = Atman = Ganesha =Durga=Murugan=(for some people) Sai Baba. @Lazy Lubber

    – S K
    1 hour ago








  • 5





    1=2 for some people

    – ram
    1 hour ago











  • Bhakti and jnana.

    – Lazy Lubber
    1 hour ago











  • Vedanta is itself bhakti. Vedanta teaches both bhakti and jnana. Bhakti=Jnana

    – Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
    1 hour ago














0












0








0








First of all - "Govinda" not being "Narayana" can refer to any deity even by Vaishnavite rules.



But then a blog named [shastranethralaya](
http://blog.shastranethralaya.org/?p=165)



says




Normally this is taken as a Bhakti text. But we’ll see it in its true form, like any other Acharya’s text this is also another which deals only with Vedanta.







So this stanzas summary is, they have to worship the Lord who is none other than the Self instead of wasting our time in different forms of action. Since no action can make us attain the ever attained.











share|improve this question
















First of all - "Govinda" not being "Narayana" can refer to any deity even by Vaishnavite rules.



But then a blog named [shastranethralaya](
http://blog.shastranethralaya.org/?p=165)



says




Normally this is taken as a Bhakti text. But we’ll see it in its true form, like any other Acharya’s text this is also another which deals only with Vedanta.







So this stanzas summary is, they have to worship the Lord who is none other than the Self instead of wasting our time in different forms of action. Since no action can make us attain the ever attained.








krishna adi-shankaracharya stotra






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 1 hour ago







S K

















asked 1 hour ago









S KS K

5,1511230




5,1511230













  • Yes, Govinda = Krishna = Vishnu = brahman = Atman

    – Lazy Lubber
    1 hour ago











  • Govinda = Krishna = Vishnu = brahman = Atman = Ganesha =Durga=Murugan=(for some people) Sai Baba. @Lazy Lubber

    – S K
    1 hour ago








  • 5





    1=2 for some people

    – ram
    1 hour ago











  • Bhakti and jnana.

    – Lazy Lubber
    1 hour ago











  • Vedanta is itself bhakti. Vedanta teaches both bhakti and jnana. Bhakti=Jnana

    – Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
    1 hour ago



















  • Yes, Govinda = Krishna = Vishnu = brahman = Atman

    – Lazy Lubber
    1 hour ago











  • Govinda = Krishna = Vishnu = brahman = Atman = Ganesha =Durga=Murugan=(for some people) Sai Baba. @Lazy Lubber

    – S K
    1 hour ago








  • 5





    1=2 for some people

    – ram
    1 hour ago











  • Bhakti and jnana.

    – Lazy Lubber
    1 hour ago











  • Vedanta is itself bhakti. Vedanta teaches both bhakti and jnana. Bhakti=Jnana

    – Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
    1 hour ago

















Yes, Govinda = Krishna = Vishnu = brahman = Atman

– Lazy Lubber
1 hour ago





Yes, Govinda = Krishna = Vishnu = brahman = Atman

– Lazy Lubber
1 hour ago













Govinda = Krishna = Vishnu = brahman = Atman = Ganesha =Durga=Murugan=(for some people) Sai Baba. @Lazy Lubber

– S K
1 hour ago







Govinda = Krishna = Vishnu = brahman = Atman = Ganesha =Durga=Murugan=(for some people) Sai Baba. @Lazy Lubber

– S K
1 hour ago






5




5





1=2 for some people

– ram
1 hour ago





1=2 for some people

– ram
1 hour ago













Bhakti and jnana.

– Lazy Lubber
1 hour ago





Bhakti and jnana.

– Lazy Lubber
1 hour ago













Vedanta is itself bhakti. Vedanta teaches both bhakti and jnana. Bhakti=Jnana

– Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
1 hour ago





Vedanta is itself bhakti. Vedanta teaches both bhakti and jnana. Bhakti=Jnana

– Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
1 hour ago










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes


















5














From the VERY EXACT SAME blog article, at the beginning of the shloka's explanation




Bhaja Govindam Bhaja Govindam – Definetly worship Govinda (Krishna)




I have bolded the word Krishna (it's in black color) in case it's not easily visible.






share|improve this answer
























  • This is so dishonest as the article says "Normally this is taken as a Bhakti text. But we’ll see it in its true form, like any other Acharya’s text this is also another which deals only with Vedanta."

    – S K
    1 hour ago








  • 3





    @SK. if you find the article dishonest maybe you should take it up with those who wrote it.

    – ram
    1 hour ago








  • 1





    This answer is savage lol 😎

    – Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
    39 mins ago



















5














Bhaja Govindam stotra is attributed to Krishna or Vishnu.



The author of Bhaja Govindam stotra is Adi Shankaracharya. He also wrote commentary on Vishnu Sahasranama. He gave a detailed explanation of the name Govinda. Not one or two, more than that.



From The Vishnu Sahasranama Bhashya with Adi Shankara commentary"




The Mahabharata, Mokshadharma (San., 343-41) says: "I first knew (vinda) the Earth (go) which was carried away and hidden in a cave (by an Asura), hence I am praised by the appellation 'Govinda' by Gods, and Scriptures." The Harivamsa (76-45 and 279-49) says: "I am Indra (Lord) over the Devas, thou art lord over the cows, hence the world will ever praise Thee as , Govinda '; speech is named 'Go,' and since thou conferest speech, 0 Lord, the Sages call you 'Govinda'."



Ka Go+ Vide has the following tell meanings: Go

1. Svarga (Heaven). He transcends the Heaven.

2. Arrows (He knows all the weapons).

3. Cattle. He is the leader of the ignorant ones.

4. Speech. He is to be known by the Vedas.

5. Thunderbolt; He has the Vajra marks on his feet.

6. Quarters; He is known in all quarters.

7. eyes; He is in the person residing in the eyes.

8. The sun ; He is in the form of the Sun.

9. Earth; He recovered the Earth from the Titans.

10. Waters; His seat is in the waters.

And Vid, to know.




He quotes the incident of Lord Vishnu's avatar Varaha saving Earth from Hiranyaksha and also Harivamsa incident where Indra praises Lord Krishna to show the name Govinda referring to Vishnu and Krishna (Adi Shankaracharya does not see difference between the two). Hence, the author's words need to taken as a reference and authority.



Hence, we can undoubtedly say Bhaja Govindam stotra is dedicated to Lord Krishna.



It is a Bhakti text because it says the people to recite the name of God. It recommends devotional path by chanting Lord's name. It is also a Vedanta text because in the stotra, Adi Shankara explains how a person in a samsara totally wastes his time assuming wealth, family and mortal life etc., as important. He asks us to concentrate on the reality and get out of the maya. It was originally called Moha Mudgaara (a hammer to shatter illusion). Vedanta teaches that there is only one reality and asks us to get out of maya. Hence, the stotra is not only a Bhakti text but also a Vedantic text.






share|improve this answer

































    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes








    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes









    5














    From the VERY EXACT SAME blog article, at the beginning of the shloka's explanation




    Bhaja Govindam Bhaja Govindam – Definetly worship Govinda (Krishna)




    I have bolded the word Krishna (it's in black color) in case it's not easily visible.






    share|improve this answer
























    • This is so dishonest as the article says "Normally this is taken as a Bhakti text. But we’ll see it in its true form, like any other Acharya’s text this is also another which deals only with Vedanta."

      – S K
      1 hour ago








    • 3





      @SK. if you find the article dishonest maybe you should take it up with those who wrote it.

      – ram
      1 hour ago








    • 1





      This answer is savage lol 😎

      – Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
      39 mins ago
















    5














    From the VERY EXACT SAME blog article, at the beginning of the shloka's explanation




    Bhaja Govindam Bhaja Govindam – Definetly worship Govinda (Krishna)




    I have bolded the word Krishna (it's in black color) in case it's not easily visible.






    share|improve this answer
























    • This is so dishonest as the article says "Normally this is taken as a Bhakti text. But we’ll see it in its true form, like any other Acharya’s text this is also another which deals only with Vedanta."

      – S K
      1 hour ago








    • 3





      @SK. if you find the article dishonest maybe you should take it up with those who wrote it.

      – ram
      1 hour ago








    • 1





      This answer is savage lol 😎

      – Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
      39 mins ago














    5












    5








    5







    From the VERY EXACT SAME blog article, at the beginning of the shloka's explanation




    Bhaja Govindam Bhaja Govindam – Definetly worship Govinda (Krishna)




    I have bolded the word Krishna (it's in black color) in case it's not easily visible.






    share|improve this answer













    From the VERY EXACT SAME blog article, at the beginning of the shloka's explanation




    Bhaja Govindam Bhaja Govindam – Definetly worship Govinda (Krishna)




    I have bolded the word Krishna (it's in black color) in case it's not easily visible.







    share|improve this answer












    share|improve this answer



    share|improve this answer










    answered 1 hour ago









    ramram

    3,83611334




    3,83611334













    • This is so dishonest as the article says "Normally this is taken as a Bhakti text. But we’ll see it in its true form, like any other Acharya’s text this is also another which deals only with Vedanta."

      – S K
      1 hour ago








    • 3





      @SK. if you find the article dishonest maybe you should take it up with those who wrote it.

      – ram
      1 hour ago








    • 1





      This answer is savage lol 😎

      – Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
      39 mins ago



















    • This is so dishonest as the article says "Normally this is taken as a Bhakti text. But we’ll see it in its true form, like any other Acharya’s text this is also another which deals only with Vedanta."

      – S K
      1 hour ago








    • 3





      @SK. if you find the article dishonest maybe you should take it up with those who wrote it.

      – ram
      1 hour ago








    • 1





      This answer is savage lol 😎

      – Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
      39 mins ago

















    This is so dishonest as the article says "Normally this is taken as a Bhakti text. But we’ll see it in its true form, like any other Acharya’s text this is also another which deals only with Vedanta."

    – S K
    1 hour ago







    This is so dishonest as the article says "Normally this is taken as a Bhakti text. But we’ll see it in its true form, like any other Acharya’s text this is also another which deals only with Vedanta."

    – S K
    1 hour ago






    3




    3





    @SK. if you find the article dishonest maybe you should take it up with those who wrote it.

    – ram
    1 hour ago







    @SK. if you find the article dishonest maybe you should take it up with those who wrote it.

    – ram
    1 hour ago






    1




    1





    This answer is savage lol 😎

    – Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
    39 mins ago





    This answer is savage lol 😎

    – Surya Kanta Bose Chowdhury
    39 mins ago











    5














    Bhaja Govindam stotra is attributed to Krishna or Vishnu.



    The author of Bhaja Govindam stotra is Adi Shankaracharya. He also wrote commentary on Vishnu Sahasranama. He gave a detailed explanation of the name Govinda. Not one or two, more than that.



    From The Vishnu Sahasranama Bhashya with Adi Shankara commentary"




    The Mahabharata, Mokshadharma (San., 343-41) says: "I first knew (vinda) the Earth (go) which was carried away and hidden in a cave (by an Asura), hence I am praised by the appellation 'Govinda' by Gods, and Scriptures." The Harivamsa (76-45 and 279-49) says: "I am Indra (Lord) over the Devas, thou art lord over the cows, hence the world will ever praise Thee as , Govinda '; speech is named 'Go,' and since thou conferest speech, 0 Lord, the Sages call you 'Govinda'."



    Ka Go+ Vide has the following tell meanings: Go

    1. Svarga (Heaven). He transcends the Heaven.

    2. Arrows (He knows all the weapons).

    3. Cattle. He is the leader of the ignorant ones.

    4. Speech. He is to be known by the Vedas.

    5. Thunderbolt; He has the Vajra marks on his feet.

    6. Quarters; He is known in all quarters.

    7. eyes; He is in the person residing in the eyes.

    8. The sun ; He is in the form of the Sun.

    9. Earth; He recovered the Earth from the Titans.

    10. Waters; His seat is in the waters.

    And Vid, to know.




    He quotes the incident of Lord Vishnu's avatar Varaha saving Earth from Hiranyaksha and also Harivamsa incident where Indra praises Lord Krishna to show the name Govinda referring to Vishnu and Krishna (Adi Shankaracharya does not see difference between the two). Hence, the author's words need to taken as a reference and authority.



    Hence, we can undoubtedly say Bhaja Govindam stotra is dedicated to Lord Krishna.



    It is a Bhakti text because it says the people to recite the name of God. It recommends devotional path by chanting Lord's name. It is also a Vedanta text because in the stotra, Adi Shankara explains how a person in a samsara totally wastes his time assuming wealth, family and mortal life etc., as important. He asks us to concentrate on the reality and get out of the maya. It was originally called Moha Mudgaara (a hammer to shatter illusion). Vedanta teaches that there is only one reality and asks us to get out of maya. Hence, the stotra is not only a Bhakti text but also a Vedantic text.






    share|improve this answer






























      5














      Bhaja Govindam stotra is attributed to Krishna or Vishnu.



      The author of Bhaja Govindam stotra is Adi Shankaracharya. He also wrote commentary on Vishnu Sahasranama. He gave a detailed explanation of the name Govinda. Not one or two, more than that.



      From The Vishnu Sahasranama Bhashya with Adi Shankara commentary"




      The Mahabharata, Mokshadharma (San., 343-41) says: "I first knew (vinda) the Earth (go) which was carried away and hidden in a cave (by an Asura), hence I am praised by the appellation 'Govinda' by Gods, and Scriptures." The Harivamsa (76-45 and 279-49) says: "I am Indra (Lord) over the Devas, thou art lord over the cows, hence the world will ever praise Thee as , Govinda '; speech is named 'Go,' and since thou conferest speech, 0 Lord, the Sages call you 'Govinda'."



      Ka Go+ Vide has the following tell meanings: Go

      1. Svarga (Heaven). He transcends the Heaven.

      2. Arrows (He knows all the weapons).

      3. Cattle. He is the leader of the ignorant ones.

      4. Speech. He is to be known by the Vedas.

      5. Thunderbolt; He has the Vajra marks on his feet.

      6. Quarters; He is known in all quarters.

      7. eyes; He is in the person residing in the eyes.

      8. The sun ; He is in the form of the Sun.

      9. Earth; He recovered the Earth from the Titans.

      10. Waters; His seat is in the waters.

      And Vid, to know.




      He quotes the incident of Lord Vishnu's avatar Varaha saving Earth from Hiranyaksha and also Harivamsa incident where Indra praises Lord Krishna to show the name Govinda referring to Vishnu and Krishna (Adi Shankaracharya does not see difference between the two). Hence, the author's words need to taken as a reference and authority.



      Hence, we can undoubtedly say Bhaja Govindam stotra is dedicated to Lord Krishna.



      It is a Bhakti text because it says the people to recite the name of God. It recommends devotional path by chanting Lord's name. It is also a Vedanta text because in the stotra, Adi Shankara explains how a person in a samsara totally wastes his time assuming wealth, family and mortal life etc., as important. He asks us to concentrate on the reality and get out of the maya. It was originally called Moha Mudgaara (a hammer to shatter illusion). Vedanta teaches that there is only one reality and asks us to get out of maya. Hence, the stotra is not only a Bhakti text but also a Vedantic text.






      share|improve this answer




























        5












        5








        5







        Bhaja Govindam stotra is attributed to Krishna or Vishnu.



        The author of Bhaja Govindam stotra is Adi Shankaracharya. He also wrote commentary on Vishnu Sahasranama. He gave a detailed explanation of the name Govinda. Not one or two, more than that.



        From The Vishnu Sahasranama Bhashya with Adi Shankara commentary"




        The Mahabharata, Mokshadharma (San., 343-41) says: "I first knew (vinda) the Earth (go) which was carried away and hidden in a cave (by an Asura), hence I am praised by the appellation 'Govinda' by Gods, and Scriptures." The Harivamsa (76-45 and 279-49) says: "I am Indra (Lord) over the Devas, thou art lord over the cows, hence the world will ever praise Thee as , Govinda '; speech is named 'Go,' and since thou conferest speech, 0 Lord, the Sages call you 'Govinda'."



        Ka Go+ Vide has the following tell meanings: Go

        1. Svarga (Heaven). He transcends the Heaven.

        2. Arrows (He knows all the weapons).

        3. Cattle. He is the leader of the ignorant ones.

        4. Speech. He is to be known by the Vedas.

        5. Thunderbolt; He has the Vajra marks on his feet.

        6. Quarters; He is known in all quarters.

        7. eyes; He is in the person residing in the eyes.

        8. The sun ; He is in the form of the Sun.

        9. Earth; He recovered the Earth from the Titans.

        10. Waters; His seat is in the waters.

        And Vid, to know.




        He quotes the incident of Lord Vishnu's avatar Varaha saving Earth from Hiranyaksha and also Harivamsa incident where Indra praises Lord Krishna to show the name Govinda referring to Vishnu and Krishna (Adi Shankaracharya does not see difference between the two). Hence, the author's words need to taken as a reference and authority.



        Hence, we can undoubtedly say Bhaja Govindam stotra is dedicated to Lord Krishna.



        It is a Bhakti text because it says the people to recite the name of God. It recommends devotional path by chanting Lord's name. It is also a Vedanta text because in the stotra, Adi Shankara explains how a person in a samsara totally wastes his time assuming wealth, family and mortal life etc., as important. He asks us to concentrate on the reality and get out of the maya. It was originally called Moha Mudgaara (a hammer to shatter illusion). Vedanta teaches that there is only one reality and asks us to get out of maya. Hence, the stotra is not only a Bhakti text but also a Vedantic text.






        share|improve this answer















        Bhaja Govindam stotra is attributed to Krishna or Vishnu.



        The author of Bhaja Govindam stotra is Adi Shankaracharya. He also wrote commentary on Vishnu Sahasranama. He gave a detailed explanation of the name Govinda. Not one or two, more than that.



        From The Vishnu Sahasranama Bhashya with Adi Shankara commentary"




        The Mahabharata, Mokshadharma (San., 343-41) says: "I first knew (vinda) the Earth (go) which was carried away and hidden in a cave (by an Asura), hence I am praised by the appellation 'Govinda' by Gods, and Scriptures." The Harivamsa (76-45 and 279-49) says: "I am Indra (Lord) over the Devas, thou art lord over the cows, hence the world will ever praise Thee as , Govinda '; speech is named 'Go,' and since thou conferest speech, 0 Lord, the Sages call you 'Govinda'."



        Ka Go+ Vide has the following tell meanings: Go

        1. Svarga (Heaven). He transcends the Heaven.

        2. Arrows (He knows all the weapons).

        3. Cattle. He is the leader of the ignorant ones.

        4. Speech. He is to be known by the Vedas.

        5. Thunderbolt; He has the Vajra marks on his feet.

        6. Quarters; He is known in all quarters.

        7. eyes; He is in the person residing in the eyes.

        8. The sun ; He is in the form of the Sun.

        9. Earth; He recovered the Earth from the Titans.

        10. Waters; His seat is in the waters.

        And Vid, to know.




        He quotes the incident of Lord Vishnu's avatar Varaha saving Earth from Hiranyaksha and also Harivamsa incident where Indra praises Lord Krishna to show the name Govinda referring to Vishnu and Krishna (Adi Shankaracharya does not see difference between the two). Hence, the author's words need to taken as a reference and authority.



        Hence, we can undoubtedly say Bhaja Govindam stotra is dedicated to Lord Krishna.



        It is a Bhakti text because it says the people to recite the name of God. It recommends devotional path by chanting Lord's name. It is also a Vedanta text because in the stotra, Adi Shankara explains how a person in a samsara totally wastes his time assuming wealth, family and mortal life etc., as important. He asks us to concentrate on the reality and get out of the maya. It was originally called Moha Mudgaara (a hammer to shatter illusion). Vedanta teaches that there is only one reality and asks us to get out of maya. Hence, the stotra is not only a Bhakti text but also a Vedantic text.







        share|improve this answer














        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer








        edited 4 mins ago

























        answered 43 mins ago









        SarvabhoumaSarvabhouma

        15.6k564141




        15.6k564141















            Popular posts from this blog

            How to label and detect the document text images

            Vallis Paradisi

            Tabula Rosettana