Explanation of seasons in “A Song of Ice and Fire”












75















Is there any sort of in-universe scientific explanation of the irregular seasons in "A Song of Ice and Fire". What does the orbit/tilt of their planet look like? How can a year be measured?










share|improve this question




















  • 6





    Excellent question. Especially the second part. If your seasons last for years, then how do you define a year?

    – Dima
    Apr 24 '11 at 23:06






  • 20





    @Keen: No, that doesn't seem right. The characters in the book talk about the seasons lasting for years. They also talk about their "name days" and their own ages in years. So they must have a notion of a year, similar in length to an Earth year (at least relative to their life-spans). Also it is not just their year being longer. The seasons are irregular, lasting from a couple of years to a decade.

    – Dima
    Apr 24 '11 at 23:54








  • 6





    The super-long seasons are just periods of cold and warm, not seasons in an astronomical sense. They still know it's a year by the stars.

    – MGOwen
    May 19 '11 at 3:47






  • 3





    Some math and physics wonks at ArXiv attempted to explain the long and varied seasons with a binary system, but their seasons only lasted between 600 and 800 days.

    – Nick T
    Jun 19 '13 at 21:12






  • 1





    I've edited this question to make it on-topic ("how would this work in reality" is off-topic here, but "how does this work in-universe" is fine) and improve consistency with the existing answers (all of which are about the in-universe world of aSoIaF rather than the scientific plausibility of such a world). Feel free to rollback my edit if you disagree, but in that case your question would probably have to be closed.

    – Rand al'Thor
    Dec 16 '17 at 16:35
















75















Is there any sort of in-universe scientific explanation of the irregular seasons in "A Song of Ice and Fire". What does the orbit/tilt of their planet look like? How can a year be measured?










share|improve this question




















  • 6





    Excellent question. Especially the second part. If your seasons last for years, then how do you define a year?

    – Dima
    Apr 24 '11 at 23:06






  • 20





    @Keen: No, that doesn't seem right. The characters in the book talk about the seasons lasting for years. They also talk about their "name days" and their own ages in years. So they must have a notion of a year, similar in length to an Earth year (at least relative to their life-spans). Also it is not just their year being longer. The seasons are irregular, lasting from a couple of years to a decade.

    – Dima
    Apr 24 '11 at 23:54








  • 6





    The super-long seasons are just periods of cold and warm, not seasons in an astronomical sense. They still know it's a year by the stars.

    – MGOwen
    May 19 '11 at 3:47






  • 3





    Some math and physics wonks at ArXiv attempted to explain the long and varied seasons with a binary system, but their seasons only lasted between 600 and 800 days.

    – Nick T
    Jun 19 '13 at 21:12






  • 1





    I've edited this question to make it on-topic ("how would this work in reality" is off-topic here, but "how does this work in-universe" is fine) and improve consistency with the existing answers (all of which are about the in-universe world of aSoIaF rather than the scientific plausibility of such a world). Feel free to rollback my edit if you disagree, but in that case your question would probably have to be closed.

    – Rand al'Thor
    Dec 16 '17 at 16:35














75












75








75


5






Is there any sort of in-universe scientific explanation of the irregular seasons in "A Song of Ice and Fire". What does the orbit/tilt of their planet look like? How can a year be measured?










share|improve this question
















Is there any sort of in-universe scientific explanation of the irregular seasons in "A Song of Ice and Fire". What does the orbit/tilt of their planet look like? How can a year be measured?







a-song-of-ice-and-fire






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Jun 20 '18 at 9:15









TheLethalCarrot

49.9k20272315




49.9k20272315










asked Apr 24 '11 at 22:21









BigPeteBigPete

481146




481146








  • 6





    Excellent question. Especially the second part. If your seasons last for years, then how do you define a year?

    – Dima
    Apr 24 '11 at 23:06






  • 20





    @Keen: No, that doesn't seem right. The characters in the book talk about the seasons lasting for years. They also talk about their "name days" and their own ages in years. So they must have a notion of a year, similar in length to an Earth year (at least relative to their life-spans). Also it is not just their year being longer. The seasons are irregular, lasting from a couple of years to a decade.

    – Dima
    Apr 24 '11 at 23:54








  • 6





    The super-long seasons are just periods of cold and warm, not seasons in an astronomical sense. They still know it's a year by the stars.

    – MGOwen
    May 19 '11 at 3:47






  • 3





    Some math and physics wonks at ArXiv attempted to explain the long and varied seasons with a binary system, but their seasons only lasted between 600 and 800 days.

    – Nick T
    Jun 19 '13 at 21:12






  • 1





    I've edited this question to make it on-topic ("how would this work in reality" is off-topic here, but "how does this work in-universe" is fine) and improve consistency with the existing answers (all of which are about the in-universe world of aSoIaF rather than the scientific plausibility of such a world). Feel free to rollback my edit if you disagree, but in that case your question would probably have to be closed.

    – Rand al'Thor
    Dec 16 '17 at 16:35














  • 6





    Excellent question. Especially the second part. If your seasons last for years, then how do you define a year?

    – Dima
    Apr 24 '11 at 23:06






  • 20





    @Keen: No, that doesn't seem right. The characters in the book talk about the seasons lasting for years. They also talk about their "name days" and their own ages in years. So they must have a notion of a year, similar in length to an Earth year (at least relative to their life-spans). Also it is not just their year being longer. The seasons are irregular, lasting from a couple of years to a decade.

    – Dima
    Apr 24 '11 at 23:54








  • 6





    The super-long seasons are just periods of cold and warm, not seasons in an astronomical sense. They still know it's a year by the stars.

    – MGOwen
    May 19 '11 at 3:47






  • 3





    Some math and physics wonks at ArXiv attempted to explain the long and varied seasons with a binary system, but their seasons only lasted between 600 and 800 days.

    – Nick T
    Jun 19 '13 at 21:12






  • 1





    I've edited this question to make it on-topic ("how would this work in reality" is off-topic here, but "how does this work in-universe" is fine) and improve consistency with the existing answers (all of which are about the in-universe world of aSoIaF rather than the scientific plausibility of such a world). Feel free to rollback my edit if you disagree, but in that case your question would probably have to be closed.

    – Rand al'Thor
    Dec 16 '17 at 16:35








6




6





Excellent question. Especially the second part. If your seasons last for years, then how do you define a year?

– Dima
Apr 24 '11 at 23:06





Excellent question. Especially the second part. If your seasons last for years, then how do you define a year?

– Dima
Apr 24 '11 at 23:06




20




20





@Keen: No, that doesn't seem right. The characters in the book talk about the seasons lasting for years. They also talk about their "name days" and their own ages in years. So they must have a notion of a year, similar in length to an Earth year (at least relative to their life-spans). Also it is not just their year being longer. The seasons are irregular, lasting from a couple of years to a decade.

– Dima
Apr 24 '11 at 23:54







@Keen: No, that doesn't seem right. The characters in the book talk about the seasons lasting for years. They also talk about their "name days" and their own ages in years. So they must have a notion of a year, similar in length to an Earth year (at least relative to their life-spans). Also it is not just their year being longer. The seasons are irregular, lasting from a couple of years to a decade.

– Dima
Apr 24 '11 at 23:54






6




6





The super-long seasons are just periods of cold and warm, not seasons in an astronomical sense. They still know it's a year by the stars.

– MGOwen
May 19 '11 at 3:47





The super-long seasons are just periods of cold and warm, not seasons in an astronomical sense. They still know it's a year by the stars.

– MGOwen
May 19 '11 at 3:47




3




3





Some math and physics wonks at ArXiv attempted to explain the long and varied seasons with a binary system, but their seasons only lasted between 600 and 800 days.

– Nick T
Jun 19 '13 at 21:12





Some math and physics wonks at ArXiv attempted to explain the long and varied seasons with a binary system, but their seasons only lasted between 600 and 800 days.

– Nick T
Jun 19 '13 at 21:12




1




1





I've edited this question to make it on-topic ("how would this work in reality" is off-topic here, but "how does this work in-universe" is fine) and improve consistency with the existing answers (all of which are about the in-universe world of aSoIaF rather than the scientific plausibility of such a world). Feel free to rollback my edit if you disagree, but in that case your question would probably have to be closed.

– Rand al'Thor
Dec 16 '17 at 16:35





I've edited this question to make it on-topic ("how would this work in reality" is off-topic here, but "how does this work in-universe" is fine) and improve consistency with the existing answers (all of which are about the in-universe world of aSoIaF rather than the scientific plausibility of such a world). Feel free to rollback my edit if you disagree, but in that case your question would probably have to be closed.

– Rand al'Thor
Dec 16 '17 at 16:35










8 Answers
8






active

oldest

votes


















58














As I read in an interview with the author, he said the explanation was magical and would be further explained in the last book.






share|improve this answer





















  • 5





    tor.com/blogs/2011/05/…

    – BigPete
    May 5 '11 at 0:57






  • 2





    Well, not exactly a 'scientific' answer, but it is an explanation. Too bad, I was hoping there was going to be some awesome hard science behind it.

    – BigPete
    May 5 '11 at 0:59






  • 14





    It's magic! No place for science! Hooray for the magic explanation!

    – lamwaiman1988
    May 17 '11 at 8:38






  • 1





    That's an ironic answer as GRRM once stated: "Magic can ruin things. Magic should never be the solution. Magic can be part of the problem." austinchronicle.com/daily/books/2013-08-29/…

    – Robb Vandaveer
    Nov 4 '14 at 18:43








  • 2





    @RobbVandaveer GRRM has often cited that he uses Tolkien as his "model for magic". He much prefers subtle magic, as opposed to down-right in-your-face magic use. I don't believe he is specifically against magic though.

    – Möoz
    Jan 27 '15 at 1:19



















31














I asked George R.R. Martin this at a book signing. He answered that they tell the time of year from the stars (astronomy). And the explanation for the seasons being long and unpredictable is magic (and a more in-depth answer will come in later books).






share|improve this answer



















  • 1





    Are your a contributor on Westeros.org?

    – Skooba
    Dec 16 '17 at 16:49



















15














I have a theory for the second part of your question. The planet of "A Song of Ice and Fire" has a moon. Character's often speak of the "moon's blood" as a clear euphemism for menstruation, which is a reasonable clue that a lunar cycle is at least as close to a month as it is for Luna and Earth. A year could be measured in terms of lunar cycles.



The seafaring sections of the book also make several mention of the tides, which would imply that the moon makes a fairly rapid orbit of ASOIAF's planet. Luna orbiting Earth ~once per day is what causes a 12h tidal cycle.



Having a lunar calendar makes it a lot easier for a common person with no training in astronomy to observe and measure the year. As you mention, it does seem that nearly everyone keeps track of their age & name-day. Even the wildlings have a tradition of not naming their children until they're 2 years old. (Not that the wildlings are dull or ignorant, but it would be hard to argue that another culture were less 'educated' than the wildlings.) After all, it's a lot easier to count to 12 than to 365...






share|improve this answer


























  • I can't quote it, but I remember reading that a year in Westeros is the same as a real life earth year, as in 365 days.

    – Juan
    Aug 28 '11 at 20:16






  • 3





    Historically it wasn't uncommon to delay naming an infant for some length of time, typically the delay was related to the infant mortality rates. Given the harsh conditions and way of life for Wildlings I can totally see infant mortality rates extending into child mortality. By applying the same logic waiting ~730 days doesn't seem at all unreasonable to me.

    – Scott Pack
    May 3 '14 at 15:40











  • Our Earth's tidal cycle is just under 25 hours with about 12.45 hours between high tides because the planet rotates. The rest of your answer is fine and I especially like the moon's blood comment, but it's easy to see that other than the wild climatic swings that GRRM based his planet roughly on our own.

    – Generic Geek
    Aug 30 '14 at 5:32





















5














There were possibly regular seasons in ancient history, even further back than the Age of Heroes.



Writing and records were rare even back then and most of what we know from that time is legends passed on by story. The Maesters have looked into the matter but have not been able to conclude anything as there is just not enough information from that long ago...




Though the Citadel has long sought to learn the manner by which it may predict the length and change of seasons, all efforts have been confounded. Septon Barth appeared to argue, in a fragmentary treatise, that the inconstancy of the seasons was a matter of magical art rather than trustworthy knowledge. Maester Nicol's The Measure of the Days—otherwise a laudable work containing much of use—seems influenced by this argument. Based upon his work on the movement of stars in the firmament, Nicol argues unconvincingly that the seasons might once have been of a regular length, determined solely by the way in which the globe faces the sun in its heavenly course. The notion behind it seems true enough—that the lengthening and shortening of days, if more regular, would have led to more regular seasons—but he could find no evidence that such was ever the case, beyond the most ancient of tales.



The World of Ice and Fire - Ancient History: The Long Night




The "in-universe" reasoning seems to come from GRRM's quote on the matter:




I asked "Is magic coming back into the world because there are dragons, or are dragons coming back into the world because there's magic?"
George said, "Yes. Hmm, there's excellent cheese on that pizza!" (in combination with some of the stuff he said on a panel this morning, I take it to mean that the seasons, winter and summer, are magical in nature, and he's going to reveal what it's all about eventually, but not yet.)



So Spake Martin, Entry 1282




Which was further confirmed by the co-authors of The World of Ice and Fire




But what causes these strange, unpredictable seasons? We know for certain that they’re not in any way predictable, at least not with the knowledge and observations of the people in the setting. These are “proper” seasons, though, that much we do know. If it’s summer in Westeros, it’s summer in the rest of the hemisphere, too. And yes, it really does seem to have something to do with axial tilt, much as our seasons do. It’s noted that winter means that the days grow shorter. It’s not simply that the weather becomes really cold or really warm, the planet itself appears to change its orbital dynamics in very strange and unpredictable ways.



It’s been a popular topic on the A Song of Ice and Fire forums, this whole matter of what causes the weird seasons. Suggested theories have ranged as far as suggesting dark planets in the near vicinity, perhaps a binary star, and more. But it’s rather fruitless; the author is prosaic on the topic and has provided the direct answer: it’s magic, trying to figure out a scientific, realistic explanation is bound to fail. If the magic means that some sorcerous force works on a planet-wide scale to tilt the planet this way or that… well, that’s what it means. Or is it? Can there be some combination of physical causes that would approximate the apparent-unpredictability and lengthiness of the seasons? I’ve yet to see someone manage anything convincing, but it may be an interesting puzzle for the more scientifically inclined.



How Seasons Work (Or Don’t Work) in A Song of Ice and Fire







share|improve this answer

































    4














    I am actually not sure that the long summers and winters are in effect outside of Westeros. I don't think that the same seasons are in effect in the Nine Free Cities and in Vaes Dothrak. Therefore, the long seasons are not on the whole planet, and I think it rules out an astrophysical cause.



    It looks like it's really caused by magic, and I would assume it has something to with the White Walkers.






    share|improve this answer


























    • By what do you base this on? The lack of 'irregular season' references in the other places, or is there a stated fact?

      – johnc
      May 18 '11 at 0:44








    • 2





      More than the lack of reference, the denizens of the other parts of the world seem to be indifferent to it. If the long winters were happening there as well, there would have been some cultural effects on their lifestyle. Also, the long winters seem to be tied to the White Walkers, which don't seem to exist elsewhere than northern Westeros.

      – Zottek
      May 18 '11 at 6:51











    • Granted, that does appear to be true (though I've only started book 3 so far)

      – johnc
      May 18 '11 at 10:12











    • I read in GoT wiki that at least Essos also has irregular seasons, but they are not that pronounced there, because it's more to the south. Similarly, people from the North seem to care about the Witer much more than people from other regions of Westeros.

      – svick
      Jun 18 '12 at 13:03











    • I can see the white walkers causing long winters (decades), but how would they cause summers to last years as well?

      – Trenin
      Jan 22 '14 at 17:24



















    2














    I think it has something to do with magic, and not necessarily astrophysics.



    And even if the explanation is astrophysical, maybe the tilt of their planet isn't stable, and that's what causes the irregularities.






    share|improve this answer
























    • In that case the stars would "move" and winter would be easily predicted.

      – Alveric
      Sep 7 '15 at 20:48



















    1














    It's been a while since I read the books, but I thought they had regular yearly seasonal cycles, but that these cycles were overlaid on the longer-term seasons. So, in a Winter season, you'd get warmer and colder days, but overall, it'd be much colder than during a Summer season. So, they'd be more like short-term ice ages & warming periods, than actual seasons.



    As to what could cause that? Periodic variation in volcanic activity, maybe?






    share|improve this answer































      -1














      arXiv:1304.0445




      "Winter is coming"



      Veselin Kostov, Daniel Allan, Nikolaus Hartman,
      Scott Guzewich, Justin Rogers



      Those that do not sow care little about such mundane things as
      equinoxes or planting seasons, or even crop rotation for that matter.
      Wherever and whenever the reavers reave, the mood is always foul and
      the nights are never warm or pleasant. For the rest of the good folks
      of Westeros, however, a decent grasp of the long-term weather forecast
      is a necessity. Many a maester have tried to play the Game of Weather
      Patterns and foretell when to plant those last turnip seeds, hoping
      for a few more years of balmy respite. Tried and failed. For other
      than the somewhat vague (if not outright meaningless) omens of "Winter
      is Coming", their meteorological efforts have been worse than useless.
      To right that appalling wrong, here we attempt to explain the
      apparently erratic seasonal changes in the world of G.R.R.M. A natural
      explanation for such phenomena is the unique behavior of a
      circumbinary planet. Thus, by speculating that the planet under
      scrutiny is orbiting a pair of stars, we utilize the power of
      numerical three-body dynamics to predict that, unfortunately, it is
      not possible to predict either the length, or the severity of any
      coming winter. We conclude that, alas, the Maesters were right -- one
      can only throw their hands in the air in frustration and, defeated by
      non-analytic solutions, mumble "Coming winter? May be long and nasty
      (~850 days, T<268K) or may be short and sweet (~600 days, T~273K). Who
      knows..."







      share|improve this answer



















      • 2





        That is interesting, but could you provide a short overview of the authors' conclusion, i.e. what exactly is the deal with seasons?

        – Gallifreyan
        Mar 19 '17 at 9:45












      Your Answer








      StackExchange.ready(function() {
      var channelOptions = {
      tags: "".split(" "),
      id: "186"
      };
      initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

      StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
      // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
      if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
      StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
      createEditor();
      });
      }
      else {
      createEditor();
      }
      });

      function createEditor() {
      StackExchange.prepareEditor({
      heartbeatType: 'answer',
      autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
      convertImagesToLinks: false,
      noModals: true,
      showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
      reputationToPostImages: null,
      bindNavPrevention: true,
      postfix: "",
      imageUploader: {
      brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
      contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
      allowUrls: true
      },
      noCode: true, onDemand: true,
      discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
      ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
      });


      }
      });














      draft saved

      draft discarded


















      StackExchange.ready(
      function () {
      StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3008%2fexplanation-of-seasons-in-a-song-of-ice-and-fire%23new-answer', 'question_page');
      }
      );

      Post as a guest















      Required, but never shown

























      8 Answers
      8






      active

      oldest

      votes








      8 Answers
      8






      active

      oldest

      votes









      active

      oldest

      votes






      active

      oldest

      votes









      58














      As I read in an interview with the author, he said the explanation was magical and would be further explained in the last book.






      share|improve this answer





















      • 5





        tor.com/blogs/2011/05/…

        – BigPete
        May 5 '11 at 0:57






      • 2





        Well, not exactly a 'scientific' answer, but it is an explanation. Too bad, I was hoping there was going to be some awesome hard science behind it.

        – BigPete
        May 5 '11 at 0:59






      • 14





        It's magic! No place for science! Hooray for the magic explanation!

        – lamwaiman1988
        May 17 '11 at 8:38






      • 1





        That's an ironic answer as GRRM once stated: "Magic can ruin things. Magic should never be the solution. Magic can be part of the problem." austinchronicle.com/daily/books/2013-08-29/…

        – Robb Vandaveer
        Nov 4 '14 at 18:43








      • 2





        @RobbVandaveer GRRM has often cited that he uses Tolkien as his "model for magic". He much prefers subtle magic, as opposed to down-right in-your-face magic use. I don't believe he is specifically against magic though.

        – Möoz
        Jan 27 '15 at 1:19
















      58














      As I read in an interview with the author, he said the explanation was magical and would be further explained in the last book.






      share|improve this answer





















      • 5





        tor.com/blogs/2011/05/…

        – BigPete
        May 5 '11 at 0:57






      • 2





        Well, not exactly a 'scientific' answer, but it is an explanation. Too bad, I was hoping there was going to be some awesome hard science behind it.

        – BigPete
        May 5 '11 at 0:59






      • 14





        It's magic! No place for science! Hooray for the magic explanation!

        – lamwaiman1988
        May 17 '11 at 8:38






      • 1





        That's an ironic answer as GRRM once stated: "Magic can ruin things. Magic should never be the solution. Magic can be part of the problem." austinchronicle.com/daily/books/2013-08-29/…

        – Robb Vandaveer
        Nov 4 '14 at 18:43








      • 2





        @RobbVandaveer GRRM has often cited that he uses Tolkien as his "model for magic". He much prefers subtle magic, as opposed to down-right in-your-face magic use. I don't believe he is specifically against magic though.

        – Möoz
        Jan 27 '15 at 1:19














      58












      58








      58







      As I read in an interview with the author, he said the explanation was magical and would be further explained in the last book.






      share|improve this answer















      As I read in an interview with the author, he said the explanation was magical and would be further explained in the last book.







      share|improve this answer














      share|improve this answer



      share|improve this answer








      edited Jun 18 '12 at 13:14









      svick

      557518




      557518










      answered Apr 26 '11 at 12:06









      rbottelrbottel

      78255




      78255








      • 5





        tor.com/blogs/2011/05/…

        – BigPete
        May 5 '11 at 0:57






      • 2





        Well, not exactly a 'scientific' answer, but it is an explanation. Too bad, I was hoping there was going to be some awesome hard science behind it.

        – BigPete
        May 5 '11 at 0:59






      • 14





        It's magic! No place for science! Hooray for the magic explanation!

        – lamwaiman1988
        May 17 '11 at 8:38






      • 1





        That's an ironic answer as GRRM once stated: "Magic can ruin things. Magic should never be the solution. Magic can be part of the problem." austinchronicle.com/daily/books/2013-08-29/…

        – Robb Vandaveer
        Nov 4 '14 at 18:43








      • 2





        @RobbVandaveer GRRM has often cited that he uses Tolkien as his "model for magic". He much prefers subtle magic, as opposed to down-right in-your-face magic use. I don't believe he is specifically against magic though.

        – Möoz
        Jan 27 '15 at 1:19














      • 5





        tor.com/blogs/2011/05/…

        – BigPete
        May 5 '11 at 0:57






      • 2





        Well, not exactly a 'scientific' answer, but it is an explanation. Too bad, I was hoping there was going to be some awesome hard science behind it.

        – BigPete
        May 5 '11 at 0:59






      • 14





        It's magic! No place for science! Hooray for the magic explanation!

        – lamwaiman1988
        May 17 '11 at 8:38






      • 1





        That's an ironic answer as GRRM once stated: "Magic can ruin things. Magic should never be the solution. Magic can be part of the problem." austinchronicle.com/daily/books/2013-08-29/…

        – Robb Vandaveer
        Nov 4 '14 at 18:43








      • 2





        @RobbVandaveer GRRM has often cited that he uses Tolkien as his "model for magic". He much prefers subtle magic, as opposed to down-right in-your-face magic use. I don't believe he is specifically against magic though.

        – Möoz
        Jan 27 '15 at 1:19








      5




      5





      tor.com/blogs/2011/05/…

      – BigPete
      May 5 '11 at 0:57





      tor.com/blogs/2011/05/…

      – BigPete
      May 5 '11 at 0:57




      2




      2





      Well, not exactly a 'scientific' answer, but it is an explanation. Too bad, I was hoping there was going to be some awesome hard science behind it.

      – BigPete
      May 5 '11 at 0:59





      Well, not exactly a 'scientific' answer, but it is an explanation. Too bad, I was hoping there was going to be some awesome hard science behind it.

      – BigPete
      May 5 '11 at 0:59




      14




      14





      It's magic! No place for science! Hooray for the magic explanation!

      – lamwaiman1988
      May 17 '11 at 8:38





      It's magic! No place for science! Hooray for the magic explanation!

      – lamwaiman1988
      May 17 '11 at 8:38




      1




      1





      That's an ironic answer as GRRM once stated: "Magic can ruin things. Magic should never be the solution. Magic can be part of the problem." austinchronicle.com/daily/books/2013-08-29/…

      – Robb Vandaveer
      Nov 4 '14 at 18:43







      That's an ironic answer as GRRM once stated: "Magic can ruin things. Magic should never be the solution. Magic can be part of the problem." austinchronicle.com/daily/books/2013-08-29/…

      – Robb Vandaveer
      Nov 4 '14 at 18:43






      2




      2





      @RobbVandaveer GRRM has often cited that he uses Tolkien as his "model for magic". He much prefers subtle magic, as opposed to down-right in-your-face magic use. I don't believe he is specifically against magic though.

      – Möoz
      Jan 27 '15 at 1:19





      @RobbVandaveer GRRM has often cited that he uses Tolkien as his "model for magic". He much prefers subtle magic, as opposed to down-right in-your-face magic use. I don't believe he is specifically against magic though.

      – Möoz
      Jan 27 '15 at 1:19













      31














      I asked George R.R. Martin this at a book signing. He answered that they tell the time of year from the stars (astronomy). And the explanation for the seasons being long and unpredictable is magic (and a more in-depth answer will come in later books).






      share|improve this answer



















      • 1





        Are your a contributor on Westeros.org?

        – Skooba
        Dec 16 '17 at 16:49
















      31














      I asked George R.R. Martin this at a book signing. He answered that they tell the time of year from the stars (astronomy). And the explanation for the seasons being long and unpredictable is magic (and a more in-depth answer will come in later books).






      share|improve this answer



















      • 1





        Are your a contributor on Westeros.org?

        – Skooba
        Dec 16 '17 at 16:49














      31












      31








      31







      I asked George R.R. Martin this at a book signing. He answered that they tell the time of year from the stars (astronomy). And the explanation for the seasons being long and unpredictable is magic (and a more in-depth answer will come in later books).






      share|improve this answer













      I asked George R.R. Martin this at a book signing. He answered that they tell the time of year from the stars (astronomy). And the explanation for the seasons being long and unpredictable is magic (and a more in-depth answer will come in later books).







      share|improve this answer












      share|improve this answer



      share|improve this answer










      answered Aug 28 '11 at 0:33









      AquasAquas

      31132




      31132








      • 1





        Are your a contributor on Westeros.org?

        – Skooba
        Dec 16 '17 at 16:49














      • 1





        Are your a contributor on Westeros.org?

        – Skooba
        Dec 16 '17 at 16:49








      1




      1





      Are your a contributor on Westeros.org?

      – Skooba
      Dec 16 '17 at 16:49





      Are your a contributor on Westeros.org?

      – Skooba
      Dec 16 '17 at 16:49











      15














      I have a theory for the second part of your question. The planet of "A Song of Ice and Fire" has a moon. Character's often speak of the "moon's blood" as a clear euphemism for menstruation, which is a reasonable clue that a lunar cycle is at least as close to a month as it is for Luna and Earth. A year could be measured in terms of lunar cycles.



      The seafaring sections of the book also make several mention of the tides, which would imply that the moon makes a fairly rapid orbit of ASOIAF's planet. Luna orbiting Earth ~once per day is what causes a 12h tidal cycle.



      Having a lunar calendar makes it a lot easier for a common person with no training in astronomy to observe and measure the year. As you mention, it does seem that nearly everyone keeps track of their age & name-day. Even the wildlings have a tradition of not naming their children until they're 2 years old. (Not that the wildlings are dull or ignorant, but it would be hard to argue that another culture were less 'educated' than the wildlings.) After all, it's a lot easier to count to 12 than to 365...






      share|improve this answer


























      • I can't quote it, but I remember reading that a year in Westeros is the same as a real life earth year, as in 365 days.

        – Juan
        Aug 28 '11 at 20:16






      • 3





        Historically it wasn't uncommon to delay naming an infant for some length of time, typically the delay was related to the infant mortality rates. Given the harsh conditions and way of life for Wildlings I can totally see infant mortality rates extending into child mortality. By applying the same logic waiting ~730 days doesn't seem at all unreasonable to me.

        – Scott Pack
        May 3 '14 at 15:40











      • Our Earth's tidal cycle is just under 25 hours with about 12.45 hours between high tides because the planet rotates. The rest of your answer is fine and I especially like the moon's blood comment, but it's easy to see that other than the wild climatic swings that GRRM based his planet roughly on our own.

        – Generic Geek
        Aug 30 '14 at 5:32


















      15














      I have a theory for the second part of your question. The planet of "A Song of Ice and Fire" has a moon. Character's often speak of the "moon's blood" as a clear euphemism for menstruation, which is a reasonable clue that a lunar cycle is at least as close to a month as it is for Luna and Earth. A year could be measured in terms of lunar cycles.



      The seafaring sections of the book also make several mention of the tides, which would imply that the moon makes a fairly rapid orbit of ASOIAF's planet. Luna orbiting Earth ~once per day is what causes a 12h tidal cycle.



      Having a lunar calendar makes it a lot easier for a common person with no training in astronomy to observe and measure the year. As you mention, it does seem that nearly everyone keeps track of their age & name-day. Even the wildlings have a tradition of not naming their children until they're 2 years old. (Not that the wildlings are dull or ignorant, but it would be hard to argue that another culture were less 'educated' than the wildlings.) After all, it's a lot easier to count to 12 than to 365...






      share|improve this answer


























      • I can't quote it, but I remember reading that a year in Westeros is the same as a real life earth year, as in 365 days.

        – Juan
        Aug 28 '11 at 20:16






      • 3





        Historically it wasn't uncommon to delay naming an infant for some length of time, typically the delay was related to the infant mortality rates. Given the harsh conditions and way of life for Wildlings I can totally see infant mortality rates extending into child mortality. By applying the same logic waiting ~730 days doesn't seem at all unreasonable to me.

        – Scott Pack
        May 3 '14 at 15:40











      • Our Earth's tidal cycle is just under 25 hours with about 12.45 hours between high tides because the planet rotates. The rest of your answer is fine and I especially like the moon's blood comment, but it's easy to see that other than the wild climatic swings that GRRM based his planet roughly on our own.

        – Generic Geek
        Aug 30 '14 at 5:32
















      15












      15








      15







      I have a theory for the second part of your question. The planet of "A Song of Ice and Fire" has a moon. Character's often speak of the "moon's blood" as a clear euphemism for menstruation, which is a reasonable clue that a lunar cycle is at least as close to a month as it is for Luna and Earth. A year could be measured in terms of lunar cycles.



      The seafaring sections of the book also make several mention of the tides, which would imply that the moon makes a fairly rapid orbit of ASOIAF's planet. Luna orbiting Earth ~once per day is what causes a 12h tidal cycle.



      Having a lunar calendar makes it a lot easier for a common person with no training in astronomy to observe and measure the year. As you mention, it does seem that nearly everyone keeps track of their age & name-day. Even the wildlings have a tradition of not naming their children until they're 2 years old. (Not that the wildlings are dull or ignorant, but it would be hard to argue that another culture were less 'educated' than the wildlings.) After all, it's a lot easier to count to 12 than to 365...






      share|improve this answer















      I have a theory for the second part of your question. The planet of "A Song of Ice and Fire" has a moon. Character's often speak of the "moon's blood" as a clear euphemism for menstruation, which is a reasonable clue that a lunar cycle is at least as close to a month as it is for Luna and Earth. A year could be measured in terms of lunar cycles.



      The seafaring sections of the book also make several mention of the tides, which would imply that the moon makes a fairly rapid orbit of ASOIAF's planet. Luna orbiting Earth ~once per day is what causes a 12h tidal cycle.



      Having a lunar calendar makes it a lot easier for a common person with no training in astronomy to observe and measure the year. As you mention, it does seem that nearly everyone keeps track of their age & name-day. Even the wildlings have a tradition of not naming their children until they're 2 years old. (Not that the wildlings are dull or ignorant, but it would be hard to argue that another culture were less 'educated' than the wildlings.) After all, it's a lot easier to count to 12 than to 365...







      share|improve this answer














      share|improve this answer



      share|improve this answer








      edited Dec 19 '13 at 15:12

























      answered Apr 24 '11 at 23:09









      DimaDima

      12.9k34365




      12.9k34365













      • I can't quote it, but I remember reading that a year in Westeros is the same as a real life earth year, as in 365 days.

        – Juan
        Aug 28 '11 at 20:16






      • 3





        Historically it wasn't uncommon to delay naming an infant for some length of time, typically the delay was related to the infant mortality rates. Given the harsh conditions and way of life for Wildlings I can totally see infant mortality rates extending into child mortality. By applying the same logic waiting ~730 days doesn't seem at all unreasonable to me.

        – Scott Pack
        May 3 '14 at 15:40











      • Our Earth's tidal cycle is just under 25 hours with about 12.45 hours between high tides because the planet rotates. The rest of your answer is fine and I especially like the moon's blood comment, but it's easy to see that other than the wild climatic swings that GRRM based his planet roughly on our own.

        – Generic Geek
        Aug 30 '14 at 5:32





















      • I can't quote it, but I remember reading that a year in Westeros is the same as a real life earth year, as in 365 days.

        – Juan
        Aug 28 '11 at 20:16






      • 3





        Historically it wasn't uncommon to delay naming an infant for some length of time, typically the delay was related to the infant mortality rates. Given the harsh conditions and way of life for Wildlings I can totally see infant mortality rates extending into child mortality. By applying the same logic waiting ~730 days doesn't seem at all unreasonable to me.

        – Scott Pack
        May 3 '14 at 15:40











      • Our Earth's tidal cycle is just under 25 hours with about 12.45 hours between high tides because the planet rotates. The rest of your answer is fine and I especially like the moon's blood comment, but it's easy to see that other than the wild climatic swings that GRRM based his planet roughly on our own.

        – Generic Geek
        Aug 30 '14 at 5:32



















      I can't quote it, but I remember reading that a year in Westeros is the same as a real life earth year, as in 365 days.

      – Juan
      Aug 28 '11 at 20:16





      I can't quote it, but I remember reading that a year in Westeros is the same as a real life earth year, as in 365 days.

      – Juan
      Aug 28 '11 at 20:16




      3




      3





      Historically it wasn't uncommon to delay naming an infant for some length of time, typically the delay was related to the infant mortality rates. Given the harsh conditions and way of life for Wildlings I can totally see infant mortality rates extending into child mortality. By applying the same logic waiting ~730 days doesn't seem at all unreasonable to me.

      – Scott Pack
      May 3 '14 at 15:40





      Historically it wasn't uncommon to delay naming an infant for some length of time, typically the delay was related to the infant mortality rates. Given the harsh conditions and way of life for Wildlings I can totally see infant mortality rates extending into child mortality. By applying the same logic waiting ~730 days doesn't seem at all unreasonable to me.

      – Scott Pack
      May 3 '14 at 15:40













      Our Earth's tidal cycle is just under 25 hours with about 12.45 hours between high tides because the planet rotates. The rest of your answer is fine and I especially like the moon's blood comment, but it's easy to see that other than the wild climatic swings that GRRM based his planet roughly on our own.

      – Generic Geek
      Aug 30 '14 at 5:32







      Our Earth's tidal cycle is just under 25 hours with about 12.45 hours between high tides because the planet rotates. The rest of your answer is fine and I especially like the moon's blood comment, but it's easy to see that other than the wild climatic swings that GRRM based his planet roughly on our own.

      – Generic Geek
      Aug 30 '14 at 5:32













      5














      There were possibly regular seasons in ancient history, even further back than the Age of Heroes.



      Writing and records were rare even back then and most of what we know from that time is legends passed on by story. The Maesters have looked into the matter but have not been able to conclude anything as there is just not enough information from that long ago...




      Though the Citadel has long sought to learn the manner by which it may predict the length and change of seasons, all efforts have been confounded. Septon Barth appeared to argue, in a fragmentary treatise, that the inconstancy of the seasons was a matter of magical art rather than trustworthy knowledge. Maester Nicol's The Measure of the Days—otherwise a laudable work containing much of use—seems influenced by this argument. Based upon his work on the movement of stars in the firmament, Nicol argues unconvincingly that the seasons might once have been of a regular length, determined solely by the way in which the globe faces the sun in its heavenly course. The notion behind it seems true enough—that the lengthening and shortening of days, if more regular, would have led to more regular seasons—but he could find no evidence that such was ever the case, beyond the most ancient of tales.



      The World of Ice and Fire - Ancient History: The Long Night




      The "in-universe" reasoning seems to come from GRRM's quote on the matter:




      I asked "Is magic coming back into the world because there are dragons, or are dragons coming back into the world because there's magic?"
      George said, "Yes. Hmm, there's excellent cheese on that pizza!" (in combination with some of the stuff he said on a panel this morning, I take it to mean that the seasons, winter and summer, are magical in nature, and he's going to reveal what it's all about eventually, but not yet.)



      So Spake Martin, Entry 1282




      Which was further confirmed by the co-authors of The World of Ice and Fire




      But what causes these strange, unpredictable seasons? We know for certain that they’re not in any way predictable, at least not with the knowledge and observations of the people in the setting. These are “proper” seasons, though, that much we do know. If it’s summer in Westeros, it’s summer in the rest of the hemisphere, too. And yes, it really does seem to have something to do with axial tilt, much as our seasons do. It’s noted that winter means that the days grow shorter. It’s not simply that the weather becomes really cold or really warm, the planet itself appears to change its orbital dynamics in very strange and unpredictable ways.



      It’s been a popular topic on the A Song of Ice and Fire forums, this whole matter of what causes the weird seasons. Suggested theories have ranged as far as suggesting dark planets in the near vicinity, perhaps a binary star, and more. But it’s rather fruitless; the author is prosaic on the topic and has provided the direct answer: it’s magic, trying to figure out a scientific, realistic explanation is bound to fail. If the magic means that some sorcerous force works on a planet-wide scale to tilt the planet this way or that… well, that’s what it means. Or is it? Can there be some combination of physical causes that would approximate the apparent-unpredictability and lengthiness of the seasons? I’ve yet to see someone manage anything convincing, but it may be an interesting puzzle for the more scientifically inclined.



      How Seasons Work (Or Don’t Work) in A Song of Ice and Fire







      share|improve this answer






























        5














        There were possibly regular seasons in ancient history, even further back than the Age of Heroes.



        Writing and records were rare even back then and most of what we know from that time is legends passed on by story. The Maesters have looked into the matter but have not been able to conclude anything as there is just not enough information from that long ago...




        Though the Citadel has long sought to learn the manner by which it may predict the length and change of seasons, all efforts have been confounded. Septon Barth appeared to argue, in a fragmentary treatise, that the inconstancy of the seasons was a matter of magical art rather than trustworthy knowledge. Maester Nicol's The Measure of the Days—otherwise a laudable work containing much of use—seems influenced by this argument. Based upon his work on the movement of stars in the firmament, Nicol argues unconvincingly that the seasons might once have been of a regular length, determined solely by the way in which the globe faces the sun in its heavenly course. The notion behind it seems true enough—that the lengthening and shortening of days, if more regular, would have led to more regular seasons—but he could find no evidence that such was ever the case, beyond the most ancient of tales.



        The World of Ice and Fire - Ancient History: The Long Night




        The "in-universe" reasoning seems to come from GRRM's quote on the matter:




        I asked "Is magic coming back into the world because there are dragons, or are dragons coming back into the world because there's magic?"
        George said, "Yes. Hmm, there's excellent cheese on that pizza!" (in combination with some of the stuff he said on a panel this morning, I take it to mean that the seasons, winter and summer, are magical in nature, and he's going to reveal what it's all about eventually, but not yet.)



        So Spake Martin, Entry 1282




        Which was further confirmed by the co-authors of The World of Ice and Fire




        But what causes these strange, unpredictable seasons? We know for certain that they’re not in any way predictable, at least not with the knowledge and observations of the people in the setting. These are “proper” seasons, though, that much we do know. If it’s summer in Westeros, it’s summer in the rest of the hemisphere, too. And yes, it really does seem to have something to do with axial tilt, much as our seasons do. It’s noted that winter means that the days grow shorter. It’s not simply that the weather becomes really cold or really warm, the planet itself appears to change its orbital dynamics in very strange and unpredictable ways.



        It’s been a popular topic on the A Song of Ice and Fire forums, this whole matter of what causes the weird seasons. Suggested theories have ranged as far as suggesting dark planets in the near vicinity, perhaps a binary star, and more. But it’s rather fruitless; the author is prosaic on the topic and has provided the direct answer: it’s magic, trying to figure out a scientific, realistic explanation is bound to fail. If the magic means that some sorcerous force works on a planet-wide scale to tilt the planet this way or that… well, that’s what it means. Or is it? Can there be some combination of physical causes that would approximate the apparent-unpredictability and lengthiness of the seasons? I’ve yet to see someone manage anything convincing, but it may be an interesting puzzle for the more scientifically inclined.



        How Seasons Work (Or Don’t Work) in A Song of Ice and Fire







        share|improve this answer




























          5












          5








          5







          There were possibly regular seasons in ancient history, even further back than the Age of Heroes.



          Writing and records were rare even back then and most of what we know from that time is legends passed on by story. The Maesters have looked into the matter but have not been able to conclude anything as there is just not enough information from that long ago...




          Though the Citadel has long sought to learn the manner by which it may predict the length and change of seasons, all efforts have been confounded. Septon Barth appeared to argue, in a fragmentary treatise, that the inconstancy of the seasons was a matter of magical art rather than trustworthy knowledge. Maester Nicol's The Measure of the Days—otherwise a laudable work containing much of use—seems influenced by this argument. Based upon his work on the movement of stars in the firmament, Nicol argues unconvincingly that the seasons might once have been of a regular length, determined solely by the way in which the globe faces the sun in its heavenly course. The notion behind it seems true enough—that the lengthening and shortening of days, if more regular, would have led to more regular seasons—but he could find no evidence that such was ever the case, beyond the most ancient of tales.



          The World of Ice and Fire - Ancient History: The Long Night




          The "in-universe" reasoning seems to come from GRRM's quote on the matter:




          I asked "Is magic coming back into the world because there are dragons, or are dragons coming back into the world because there's magic?"
          George said, "Yes. Hmm, there's excellent cheese on that pizza!" (in combination with some of the stuff he said on a panel this morning, I take it to mean that the seasons, winter and summer, are magical in nature, and he's going to reveal what it's all about eventually, but not yet.)



          So Spake Martin, Entry 1282




          Which was further confirmed by the co-authors of The World of Ice and Fire




          But what causes these strange, unpredictable seasons? We know for certain that they’re not in any way predictable, at least not with the knowledge and observations of the people in the setting. These are “proper” seasons, though, that much we do know. If it’s summer in Westeros, it’s summer in the rest of the hemisphere, too. And yes, it really does seem to have something to do with axial tilt, much as our seasons do. It’s noted that winter means that the days grow shorter. It’s not simply that the weather becomes really cold or really warm, the planet itself appears to change its orbital dynamics in very strange and unpredictable ways.



          It’s been a popular topic on the A Song of Ice and Fire forums, this whole matter of what causes the weird seasons. Suggested theories have ranged as far as suggesting dark planets in the near vicinity, perhaps a binary star, and more. But it’s rather fruitless; the author is prosaic on the topic and has provided the direct answer: it’s magic, trying to figure out a scientific, realistic explanation is bound to fail. If the magic means that some sorcerous force works on a planet-wide scale to tilt the planet this way or that… well, that’s what it means. Or is it? Can there be some combination of physical causes that would approximate the apparent-unpredictability and lengthiness of the seasons? I’ve yet to see someone manage anything convincing, but it may be an interesting puzzle for the more scientifically inclined.



          How Seasons Work (Or Don’t Work) in A Song of Ice and Fire







          share|improve this answer















          There were possibly regular seasons in ancient history, even further back than the Age of Heroes.



          Writing and records were rare even back then and most of what we know from that time is legends passed on by story. The Maesters have looked into the matter but have not been able to conclude anything as there is just not enough information from that long ago...




          Though the Citadel has long sought to learn the manner by which it may predict the length and change of seasons, all efforts have been confounded. Septon Barth appeared to argue, in a fragmentary treatise, that the inconstancy of the seasons was a matter of magical art rather than trustworthy knowledge. Maester Nicol's The Measure of the Days—otherwise a laudable work containing much of use—seems influenced by this argument. Based upon his work on the movement of stars in the firmament, Nicol argues unconvincingly that the seasons might once have been of a regular length, determined solely by the way in which the globe faces the sun in its heavenly course. The notion behind it seems true enough—that the lengthening and shortening of days, if more regular, would have led to more regular seasons—but he could find no evidence that such was ever the case, beyond the most ancient of tales.



          The World of Ice and Fire - Ancient History: The Long Night




          The "in-universe" reasoning seems to come from GRRM's quote on the matter:




          I asked "Is magic coming back into the world because there are dragons, or are dragons coming back into the world because there's magic?"
          George said, "Yes. Hmm, there's excellent cheese on that pizza!" (in combination with some of the stuff he said on a panel this morning, I take it to mean that the seasons, winter and summer, are magical in nature, and he's going to reveal what it's all about eventually, but not yet.)



          So Spake Martin, Entry 1282




          Which was further confirmed by the co-authors of The World of Ice and Fire




          But what causes these strange, unpredictable seasons? We know for certain that they’re not in any way predictable, at least not with the knowledge and observations of the people in the setting. These are “proper” seasons, though, that much we do know. If it’s summer in Westeros, it’s summer in the rest of the hemisphere, too. And yes, it really does seem to have something to do with axial tilt, much as our seasons do. It’s noted that winter means that the days grow shorter. It’s not simply that the weather becomes really cold or really warm, the planet itself appears to change its orbital dynamics in very strange and unpredictable ways.



          It’s been a popular topic on the A Song of Ice and Fire forums, this whole matter of what causes the weird seasons. Suggested theories have ranged as far as suggesting dark planets in the near vicinity, perhaps a binary star, and more. But it’s rather fruitless; the author is prosaic on the topic and has provided the direct answer: it’s magic, trying to figure out a scientific, realistic explanation is bound to fail. If the magic means that some sorcerous force works on a planet-wide scale to tilt the planet this way or that… well, that’s what it means. Or is it? Can there be some combination of physical causes that would approximate the apparent-unpredictability and lengthiness of the seasons? I’ve yet to see someone manage anything convincing, but it may be an interesting puzzle for the more scientifically inclined.



          How Seasons Work (Or Don’t Work) in A Song of Ice and Fire








          share|improve this answer














          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer








          edited 27 mins ago

























          answered Dec 16 '17 at 16:45









          SkoobaSkooba

          40.3k16210270




          40.3k16210270























              4














              I am actually not sure that the long summers and winters are in effect outside of Westeros. I don't think that the same seasons are in effect in the Nine Free Cities and in Vaes Dothrak. Therefore, the long seasons are not on the whole planet, and I think it rules out an astrophysical cause.



              It looks like it's really caused by magic, and I would assume it has something to with the White Walkers.






              share|improve this answer


























              • By what do you base this on? The lack of 'irregular season' references in the other places, or is there a stated fact?

                – johnc
                May 18 '11 at 0:44








              • 2





                More than the lack of reference, the denizens of the other parts of the world seem to be indifferent to it. If the long winters were happening there as well, there would have been some cultural effects on their lifestyle. Also, the long winters seem to be tied to the White Walkers, which don't seem to exist elsewhere than northern Westeros.

                – Zottek
                May 18 '11 at 6:51











              • Granted, that does appear to be true (though I've only started book 3 so far)

                – johnc
                May 18 '11 at 10:12











              • I read in GoT wiki that at least Essos also has irregular seasons, but they are not that pronounced there, because it's more to the south. Similarly, people from the North seem to care about the Witer much more than people from other regions of Westeros.

                – svick
                Jun 18 '12 at 13:03











              • I can see the white walkers causing long winters (decades), but how would they cause summers to last years as well?

                – Trenin
                Jan 22 '14 at 17:24
















              4














              I am actually not sure that the long summers and winters are in effect outside of Westeros. I don't think that the same seasons are in effect in the Nine Free Cities and in Vaes Dothrak. Therefore, the long seasons are not on the whole planet, and I think it rules out an astrophysical cause.



              It looks like it's really caused by magic, and I would assume it has something to with the White Walkers.






              share|improve this answer


























              • By what do you base this on? The lack of 'irregular season' references in the other places, or is there a stated fact?

                – johnc
                May 18 '11 at 0:44








              • 2





                More than the lack of reference, the denizens of the other parts of the world seem to be indifferent to it. If the long winters were happening there as well, there would have been some cultural effects on their lifestyle. Also, the long winters seem to be tied to the White Walkers, which don't seem to exist elsewhere than northern Westeros.

                – Zottek
                May 18 '11 at 6:51











              • Granted, that does appear to be true (though I've only started book 3 so far)

                – johnc
                May 18 '11 at 10:12











              • I read in GoT wiki that at least Essos also has irregular seasons, but they are not that pronounced there, because it's more to the south. Similarly, people from the North seem to care about the Witer much more than people from other regions of Westeros.

                – svick
                Jun 18 '12 at 13:03











              • I can see the white walkers causing long winters (decades), but how would they cause summers to last years as well?

                – Trenin
                Jan 22 '14 at 17:24














              4












              4








              4







              I am actually not sure that the long summers and winters are in effect outside of Westeros. I don't think that the same seasons are in effect in the Nine Free Cities and in Vaes Dothrak. Therefore, the long seasons are not on the whole planet, and I think it rules out an astrophysical cause.



              It looks like it's really caused by magic, and I would assume it has something to with the White Walkers.






              share|improve this answer















              I am actually not sure that the long summers and winters are in effect outside of Westeros. I don't think that the same seasons are in effect in the Nine Free Cities and in Vaes Dothrak. Therefore, the long seasons are not on the whole planet, and I think it rules out an astrophysical cause.



              It looks like it's really caused by magic, and I would assume it has something to with the White Walkers.







              share|improve this answer














              share|improve this answer



              share|improve this answer








              edited Nov 27 '12 at 21:34









              Niall C.

              4,74653457




              4,74653457










              answered May 17 '11 at 22:03









              ZottekZottek

              1,5761417




              1,5761417













              • By what do you base this on? The lack of 'irregular season' references in the other places, or is there a stated fact?

                – johnc
                May 18 '11 at 0:44








              • 2





                More than the lack of reference, the denizens of the other parts of the world seem to be indifferent to it. If the long winters were happening there as well, there would have been some cultural effects on their lifestyle. Also, the long winters seem to be tied to the White Walkers, which don't seem to exist elsewhere than northern Westeros.

                – Zottek
                May 18 '11 at 6:51











              • Granted, that does appear to be true (though I've only started book 3 so far)

                – johnc
                May 18 '11 at 10:12











              • I read in GoT wiki that at least Essos also has irregular seasons, but they are not that pronounced there, because it's more to the south. Similarly, people from the North seem to care about the Witer much more than people from other regions of Westeros.

                – svick
                Jun 18 '12 at 13:03











              • I can see the white walkers causing long winters (decades), but how would they cause summers to last years as well?

                – Trenin
                Jan 22 '14 at 17:24



















              • By what do you base this on? The lack of 'irregular season' references in the other places, or is there a stated fact?

                – johnc
                May 18 '11 at 0:44








              • 2





                More than the lack of reference, the denizens of the other parts of the world seem to be indifferent to it. If the long winters were happening there as well, there would have been some cultural effects on their lifestyle. Also, the long winters seem to be tied to the White Walkers, which don't seem to exist elsewhere than northern Westeros.

                – Zottek
                May 18 '11 at 6:51











              • Granted, that does appear to be true (though I've only started book 3 so far)

                – johnc
                May 18 '11 at 10:12











              • I read in GoT wiki that at least Essos also has irregular seasons, but they are not that pronounced there, because it's more to the south. Similarly, people from the North seem to care about the Witer much more than people from other regions of Westeros.

                – svick
                Jun 18 '12 at 13:03











              • I can see the white walkers causing long winters (decades), but how would they cause summers to last years as well?

                – Trenin
                Jan 22 '14 at 17:24

















              By what do you base this on? The lack of 'irregular season' references in the other places, or is there a stated fact?

              – johnc
              May 18 '11 at 0:44







              By what do you base this on? The lack of 'irregular season' references in the other places, or is there a stated fact?

              – johnc
              May 18 '11 at 0:44






              2




              2





              More than the lack of reference, the denizens of the other parts of the world seem to be indifferent to it. If the long winters were happening there as well, there would have been some cultural effects on their lifestyle. Also, the long winters seem to be tied to the White Walkers, which don't seem to exist elsewhere than northern Westeros.

              – Zottek
              May 18 '11 at 6:51





              More than the lack of reference, the denizens of the other parts of the world seem to be indifferent to it. If the long winters were happening there as well, there would have been some cultural effects on their lifestyle. Also, the long winters seem to be tied to the White Walkers, which don't seem to exist elsewhere than northern Westeros.

              – Zottek
              May 18 '11 at 6:51













              Granted, that does appear to be true (though I've only started book 3 so far)

              – johnc
              May 18 '11 at 10:12





              Granted, that does appear to be true (though I've only started book 3 so far)

              – johnc
              May 18 '11 at 10:12













              I read in GoT wiki that at least Essos also has irregular seasons, but they are not that pronounced there, because it's more to the south. Similarly, people from the North seem to care about the Witer much more than people from other regions of Westeros.

              – svick
              Jun 18 '12 at 13:03





              I read in GoT wiki that at least Essos also has irregular seasons, but they are not that pronounced there, because it's more to the south. Similarly, people from the North seem to care about the Witer much more than people from other regions of Westeros.

              – svick
              Jun 18 '12 at 13:03













              I can see the white walkers causing long winters (decades), but how would they cause summers to last years as well?

              – Trenin
              Jan 22 '14 at 17:24





              I can see the white walkers causing long winters (decades), but how would they cause summers to last years as well?

              – Trenin
              Jan 22 '14 at 17:24











              2














              I think it has something to do with magic, and not necessarily astrophysics.



              And even if the explanation is astrophysical, maybe the tilt of their planet isn't stable, and that's what causes the irregularities.






              share|improve this answer
























              • In that case the stars would "move" and winter would be easily predicted.

                – Alveric
                Sep 7 '15 at 20:48
















              2














              I think it has something to do with magic, and not necessarily astrophysics.



              And even if the explanation is astrophysical, maybe the tilt of their planet isn't stable, and that's what causes the irregularities.






              share|improve this answer
























              • In that case the stars would "move" and winter would be easily predicted.

                – Alveric
                Sep 7 '15 at 20:48














              2












              2








              2







              I think it has something to do with magic, and not necessarily astrophysics.



              And even if the explanation is astrophysical, maybe the tilt of their planet isn't stable, and that's what causes the irregularities.






              share|improve this answer













              I think it has something to do with magic, and not necessarily astrophysics.



              And even if the explanation is astrophysical, maybe the tilt of their planet isn't stable, and that's what causes the irregularities.







              share|improve this answer












              share|improve this answer



              share|improve this answer










              answered Apr 25 '11 at 7:35









              Vitaly MijiritskyVitaly Mijiritsky

              1,1201813




              1,1201813













              • In that case the stars would "move" and winter would be easily predicted.

                – Alveric
                Sep 7 '15 at 20:48



















              • In that case the stars would "move" and winter would be easily predicted.

                – Alveric
                Sep 7 '15 at 20:48

















              In that case the stars would "move" and winter would be easily predicted.

              – Alveric
              Sep 7 '15 at 20:48





              In that case the stars would "move" and winter would be easily predicted.

              – Alveric
              Sep 7 '15 at 20:48











              1














              It's been a while since I read the books, but I thought they had regular yearly seasonal cycles, but that these cycles were overlaid on the longer-term seasons. So, in a Winter season, you'd get warmer and colder days, but overall, it'd be much colder than during a Summer season. So, they'd be more like short-term ice ages & warming periods, than actual seasons.



              As to what could cause that? Periodic variation in volcanic activity, maybe?






              share|improve this answer




























                1














                It's been a while since I read the books, but I thought they had regular yearly seasonal cycles, but that these cycles were overlaid on the longer-term seasons. So, in a Winter season, you'd get warmer and colder days, but overall, it'd be much colder than during a Summer season. So, they'd be more like short-term ice ages & warming periods, than actual seasons.



                As to what could cause that? Periodic variation in volcanic activity, maybe?






                share|improve this answer


























                  1












                  1








                  1







                  It's been a while since I read the books, but I thought they had regular yearly seasonal cycles, but that these cycles were overlaid on the longer-term seasons. So, in a Winter season, you'd get warmer and colder days, but overall, it'd be much colder than during a Summer season. So, they'd be more like short-term ice ages & warming periods, than actual seasons.



                  As to what could cause that? Periodic variation in volcanic activity, maybe?






                  share|improve this answer













                  It's been a while since I read the books, but I thought they had regular yearly seasonal cycles, but that these cycles were overlaid on the longer-term seasons. So, in a Winter season, you'd get warmer and colder days, but overall, it'd be much colder than during a Summer season. So, they'd be more like short-term ice ages & warming periods, than actual seasons.



                  As to what could cause that? Periodic variation in volcanic activity, maybe?







                  share|improve this answer












                  share|improve this answer



                  share|improve this answer










                  answered Apr 25 '11 at 7:13









                  Mark BesseyMark Bessey

                  3,55911617




                  3,55911617























                      -1














                      arXiv:1304.0445




                      "Winter is coming"



                      Veselin Kostov, Daniel Allan, Nikolaus Hartman,
                      Scott Guzewich, Justin Rogers



                      Those that do not sow care little about such mundane things as
                      equinoxes or planting seasons, or even crop rotation for that matter.
                      Wherever and whenever the reavers reave, the mood is always foul and
                      the nights are never warm or pleasant. For the rest of the good folks
                      of Westeros, however, a decent grasp of the long-term weather forecast
                      is a necessity. Many a maester have tried to play the Game of Weather
                      Patterns and foretell when to plant those last turnip seeds, hoping
                      for a few more years of balmy respite. Tried and failed. For other
                      than the somewhat vague (if not outright meaningless) omens of "Winter
                      is Coming", their meteorological efforts have been worse than useless.
                      To right that appalling wrong, here we attempt to explain the
                      apparently erratic seasonal changes in the world of G.R.R.M. A natural
                      explanation for such phenomena is the unique behavior of a
                      circumbinary planet. Thus, by speculating that the planet under
                      scrutiny is orbiting a pair of stars, we utilize the power of
                      numerical three-body dynamics to predict that, unfortunately, it is
                      not possible to predict either the length, or the severity of any
                      coming winter. We conclude that, alas, the Maesters were right -- one
                      can only throw their hands in the air in frustration and, defeated by
                      non-analytic solutions, mumble "Coming winter? May be long and nasty
                      (~850 days, T<268K) or may be short and sweet (~600 days, T~273K). Who
                      knows..."







                      share|improve this answer



















                      • 2





                        That is interesting, but could you provide a short overview of the authors' conclusion, i.e. what exactly is the deal with seasons?

                        – Gallifreyan
                        Mar 19 '17 at 9:45
















                      -1














                      arXiv:1304.0445




                      "Winter is coming"



                      Veselin Kostov, Daniel Allan, Nikolaus Hartman,
                      Scott Guzewich, Justin Rogers



                      Those that do not sow care little about such mundane things as
                      equinoxes or planting seasons, or even crop rotation for that matter.
                      Wherever and whenever the reavers reave, the mood is always foul and
                      the nights are never warm or pleasant. For the rest of the good folks
                      of Westeros, however, a decent grasp of the long-term weather forecast
                      is a necessity. Many a maester have tried to play the Game of Weather
                      Patterns and foretell when to plant those last turnip seeds, hoping
                      for a few more years of balmy respite. Tried and failed. For other
                      than the somewhat vague (if not outright meaningless) omens of "Winter
                      is Coming", their meteorological efforts have been worse than useless.
                      To right that appalling wrong, here we attempt to explain the
                      apparently erratic seasonal changes in the world of G.R.R.M. A natural
                      explanation for such phenomena is the unique behavior of a
                      circumbinary planet. Thus, by speculating that the planet under
                      scrutiny is orbiting a pair of stars, we utilize the power of
                      numerical three-body dynamics to predict that, unfortunately, it is
                      not possible to predict either the length, or the severity of any
                      coming winter. We conclude that, alas, the Maesters were right -- one
                      can only throw their hands in the air in frustration and, defeated by
                      non-analytic solutions, mumble "Coming winter? May be long and nasty
                      (~850 days, T<268K) or may be short and sweet (~600 days, T~273K). Who
                      knows..."







                      share|improve this answer



















                      • 2





                        That is interesting, but could you provide a short overview of the authors' conclusion, i.e. what exactly is the deal with seasons?

                        – Gallifreyan
                        Mar 19 '17 at 9:45














                      -1












                      -1








                      -1







                      arXiv:1304.0445




                      "Winter is coming"



                      Veselin Kostov, Daniel Allan, Nikolaus Hartman,
                      Scott Guzewich, Justin Rogers



                      Those that do not sow care little about such mundane things as
                      equinoxes or planting seasons, or even crop rotation for that matter.
                      Wherever and whenever the reavers reave, the mood is always foul and
                      the nights are never warm or pleasant. For the rest of the good folks
                      of Westeros, however, a decent grasp of the long-term weather forecast
                      is a necessity. Many a maester have tried to play the Game of Weather
                      Patterns and foretell when to plant those last turnip seeds, hoping
                      for a few more years of balmy respite. Tried and failed. For other
                      than the somewhat vague (if not outright meaningless) omens of "Winter
                      is Coming", their meteorological efforts have been worse than useless.
                      To right that appalling wrong, here we attempt to explain the
                      apparently erratic seasonal changes in the world of G.R.R.M. A natural
                      explanation for such phenomena is the unique behavior of a
                      circumbinary planet. Thus, by speculating that the planet under
                      scrutiny is orbiting a pair of stars, we utilize the power of
                      numerical three-body dynamics to predict that, unfortunately, it is
                      not possible to predict either the length, or the severity of any
                      coming winter. We conclude that, alas, the Maesters were right -- one
                      can only throw their hands in the air in frustration and, defeated by
                      non-analytic solutions, mumble "Coming winter? May be long and nasty
                      (~850 days, T<268K) or may be short and sweet (~600 days, T~273K). Who
                      knows..."







                      share|improve this answer













                      arXiv:1304.0445




                      "Winter is coming"



                      Veselin Kostov, Daniel Allan, Nikolaus Hartman,
                      Scott Guzewich, Justin Rogers



                      Those that do not sow care little about such mundane things as
                      equinoxes or planting seasons, or even crop rotation for that matter.
                      Wherever and whenever the reavers reave, the mood is always foul and
                      the nights are never warm or pleasant. For the rest of the good folks
                      of Westeros, however, a decent grasp of the long-term weather forecast
                      is a necessity. Many a maester have tried to play the Game of Weather
                      Patterns and foretell when to plant those last turnip seeds, hoping
                      for a few more years of balmy respite. Tried and failed. For other
                      than the somewhat vague (if not outright meaningless) omens of "Winter
                      is Coming", their meteorological efforts have been worse than useless.
                      To right that appalling wrong, here we attempt to explain the
                      apparently erratic seasonal changes in the world of G.R.R.M. A natural
                      explanation for such phenomena is the unique behavior of a
                      circumbinary planet. Thus, by speculating that the planet under
                      scrutiny is orbiting a pair of stars, we utilize the power of
                      numerical three-body dynamics to predict that, unfortunately, it is
                      not possible to predict either the length, or the severity of any
                      coming winter. We conclude that, alas, the Maesters were right -- one
                      can only throw their hands in the air in frustration and, defeated by
                      non-analytic solutions, mumble "Coming winter? May be long and nasty
                      (~850 days, T<268K) or may be short and sweet (~600 days, T~273K). Who
                      knows..."








                      share|improve this answer












                      share|improve this answer



                      share|improve this answer










                      answered Mar 19 '17 at 9:28









                      SnowgardSnowgard

                      71




                      71








                      • 2





                        That is interesting, but could you provide a short overview of the authors' conclusion, i.e. what exactly is the deal with seasons?

                        – Gallifreyan
                        Mar 19 '17 at 9:45














                      • 2





                        That is interesting, but could you provide a short overview of the authors' conclusion, i.e. what exactly is the deal with seasons?

                        – Gallifreyan
                        Mar 19 '17 at 9:45








                      2




                      2





                      That is interesting, but could you provide a short overview of the authors' conclusion, i.e. what exactly is the deal with seasons?

                      – Gallifreyan
                      Mar 19 '17 at 9:45





                      That is interesting, but could you provide a short overview of the authors' conclusion, i.e. what exactly is the deal with seasons?

                      – Gallifreyan
                      Mar 19 '17 at 9:45


















                      draft saved

                      draft discarded




















































                      Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!


                      • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                      But avoid



                      • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                      • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


                      To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




                      draft saved


                      draft discarded














                      StackExchange.ready(
                      function () {
                      StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3008%2fexplanation-of-seasons-in-a-song-of-ice-and-fire%23new-answer', 'question_page');
                      }
                      );

                      Post as a guest















                      Required, but never shown





















































                      Required, but never shown














                      Required, but never shown












                      Required, but never shown







                      Required, but never shown

































                      Required, but never shown














                      Required, but never shown












                      Required, but never shown







                      Required, but never shown







                      Popular posts from this blog

                      Callistus I

                      Tabula Rosettana

                      How to label and detect the document text images